水资源税改革对缺水地区工业用水效率的影响

doi:10.13776/j.cnki.resourcesindustries.20220527.008

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 水资源费改税是国家以税收杠杆撬动水资源节约、推动可持续发展而出台的重要政策，自试点以来，水资源税改革取得了显著的成效，整体提高了用水效率，许多学者的研究也证实了这一重要结论。但另一个重要且尚未得到证实的问题是，工业作为我国经济发展的重要增长极的同时，也是水资源需求的主要部门，水资源税改革是否也提高了工业用水效率？为此，假设我国没有进行水资源税改革试点，采用GM（1,1）模型对水资源税改革试点后的工业用水效率进行测算，通过比较测算值和统计值，分析水资源税改革的政策效应对工业用水效率的影响。考虑到影响工业用水效率的因素有很多，故选取水资源禀赋、科技进步、环境规制、用水结构、社会因素、工业发展规模作为影响因素,并对工业用水效率的影响因素进行多元线性回归分析。通过分析发现，水资源税改革有效地提高了工业用水效率，降低了万元工业增加值用水量,并且随着改革的深入推进和企业在政策冲击下的“阵痛”期的过去，水资源税改革的政策效应会愈发明显。其中，影响工业用水效率最显著的因素是科技进步，这属于政府干预下的企业支出和财政支出。说明水资源税改革可以倒逼微观经济主体提高技术水平，从而提高工业用水效率，降低工业用水总量，缓解水资源短缺带来的压力。建议坚持节水优先，在现有基础上加大科技投入，推进节水设施和节水装置的普及程度，加快企业转型升级；在政府和市场的共同作用下，完善水资源税改革机制体制，为水资源税改革全国推开提供参考。

关键词: 水资源税改革, 工业用水效率, GM(1,1)模型, 工业企业

Abstract: Nation's water resource fee-to-tax reform is a vital policy in saving water resources and in pushing sustainable development, which has reached a large achievement in increasing water use efficiency generally, verified by many scholars. As an important growth pole of China's economic development, Industry is also the main sector of water demand. But if has the industrial water use efficiency been also increased? Given that China had not carried out this reform, this paper uses GM(1, 1) model to estimate the industrial water use efficiency after water resource fee-to-tax reform, and analyzes the impacts of water resource tax reform policy on industrial water use efficiency. Impacting factors such as water resource occurrences, technical advances, environmental regulations, water use structure, social and industrial developing sizes are selected for a multiple linear regression analysis which reveals that water resource fee-to-tax reform effectively increases the industrial water use efficiency, decreases industrial-value-added water use per 10k RMB. As such reform goes on, it will more be productive. Technical advances largely promote the industrial water use efficiency, belonging to companies' and governmental expenditure under governmental intervention. Water resource tax reform can have microscopic economic units improve technologies so as to increase industrial water use efficiency, to reduce overall industrial water use and to mitigate the pressures of water shortage. This paper suggests on saving water as a priority, boosting inputs on research, promoting water-saving devices and approaches, fastening companies' transformation and upgrading, improving water resource tax reform mechanism under a coalition of governments and markets. This study presents references for the nationwide implementation of water resource tax reform.

Key words: water resource tax reform, industrial water use efficiency, GM(1, 1) model, industrial companies

中图分类号:

F205
F812.42

田贵良, 高廷艳. 水资源税改革对缺水地区工业用水效率的影响[J]. 资源与产业, 2022, 24(3): 43-52.

TIAN Guiliang, GAO Tingyan. IMPACTS OF WATER RESOURCE TAX REFORM ON INDUSTRIAL WATER USE EFFICIENCY INWATER SHORTAGE AREAS[J]. Resources & Industries, 2022, 24(3): 43-52.

参考文献

陈少克，王银迪，2018. 水资源税的性质与我国水资源税制的发展与完善[J]. 税务与经济，(4)：98-105.〔CHEN S K, WANG Y D, 2018. Nature of water resources tax and development and improvement of China’s water resources tax system[J]. Taxation and Economy, (4): 98-105.〕

陈鹏宇，邓宏伟，2019. GM(1,1)模型的改进现状及应用[J]. 统计与决策，35(6)：80-82.

邓聚龙，2002. 灰色预测与灰决策[M]. 武汉：华中科技大学出版社.

范宝学，倪建萍，2019. 我国水资源税改革试点效应评价及改进对策[J]. 理论月刊，(8)：108-113.〔FAN B X, NI J P, 2019. Evaluation of the pilot effect of water resources tax reform in China and its countermeasures[J]. Theory Monthly, (8): 108-113.〕

郭月梅，邓静茹，苗松，2019. “1+9”试点后全面实施水资源税的探讨[J]. 税务研究，(9)：68-72.

黄凤羽，黄晶，2016. 我国水资源税的负担原则与CGE估算[J]. 税务研究，(5)：47-53.〔HUANG F Y, HUANG J, 2016. A discussion of the principle of bearing water resource tax in China and an CGE estimates[J]. Taxation Research, (5): 47-53.〕

林毅夫，2017. 产业政策与我国经济的发展：新结构经济学的视角[J]. 复旦学报(社会科学版)，59(2)：148-153.〔LIN Y F, 2017. Industrial policy and China’s economic development: from the perspective of new structural economics[J]. Fudan Journal(Social Sciences Edition), 59(2): 148-153.〕

李静，任继达，2018. 中国工业的用水效率与决定因素：资源和环境双重约束下的分析[J].工业技术经济，37(1)：122-129.〔LI J, REN J D, 2018. Study on efficiency of industrial water use in China based on MinDS model:an empirical analysis under the dual restrictions of resources and environment[J]. Journal of Industrial Technological & Economics, 37(1): 122-129.〕

李晓欢，姜亚望，高艳萍，等，2019. 水资源税改革效应分析与制度优化：以山西省为例[J].税务研究，(7)：39-45.〔LI X H, JIANG Y W, GAO Y P, et al, 2019. An analysis on the reform effect and optimization of the water resources tax system: Shanxi province as an example[J]. Taxation Research, (7): 39-45.〕

刘秀丽，郭丕斌，王昕，2020. 煤炭资源型地区产业能-水足迹效率及影响因素[J]. 生态学报，40(24)：8999-9010.〔LIU X L, GUO P B, WANG X, 2020. Industrial energy-water footprint efficiency and its influencing factors in coal resource-based areas[J]. Acta Ecologica Sinica, 40 (24): 8999-9010.〕

倪娟，王帆，唐国平，2019. 水资源税试点地区经验及全面推广对策研究[J]. 税务研究，(7)：33-38.

司言武，2009. 环境税经济效应研究：一个理论综述[J]. 社会科学战线，(6)：113-118.〔SI Y W, 2009. Research on economic effects of environmental tax: a theoretical review[J]. Social Science Front, (6): 113-118.〕

唐万梅，向长合，2006. 基于二次插值的GM(1,1)模型预测方法的改进[J]. 中国管理科学，14(6)：109-113.

王金南，2006. 环境税收政策及其实施战略[M]. 北京：中国环境出版社.

王敏，李薇，2012. 欧盟水资源税(费)政策对中国的启示[J]. 财政研究，(3)：57-60.

王克强，邓光耀，刘红梅，2015. 基于多区域CGE模型的中国农业用水效率和水资源税政策模拟研究[J]. 财经研究，41(3)：40-52,144.〔WANG K Q, DENG G Y, LIU H M, 2015. Water utilization efficiency in agriculture and policy simulation of water resources tax in China based on Multi-regional CGE model[J]. Journal of Finance and Economics, 41(3): 40-52 ,144.〕

王芳，曹一鸣，陈硕，2020. 反思环境库兹涅茨曲线假说[J]. 经济学(季刊)，19(1)：81-100.〔WANG F,CAO Y M,CHEN S, 2020. Re-thinking environmental kuznets curve hypothesis in China[J]. China Economic Quarterly, 19(1): 81-100.〕

王保乾，叶雯倩，2021. 长江经济带水资源福利绩效时空演变及空间效应研究[J]. 资源与产业，23(1)：10-19.〔WANG B Q,YE W Q, 2021. Spatial-temporal evolution and spatial effects of water resources welfare performance in Yangtze river economic zone[J]. Resources & Industries, 23 (1): 10-19.〕

许欣斌，2017. 我国水资源税改革及推进策略研究[D]. 长春：东北师范大学.

于连超，张卫国，毕茜，2019. 环境税对企业绿色转型的倒逼效应研究[J]. 中国人口. 资源与环境，29(7)：112-120.〔YU L C,ZHANG G W, BI Q, 2019. The study on the backward forcing effect of environmental tax on corporate green transformation[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 29 (7): 112-120.〕

杨得前，赵磊，杨豆豆，2020. 水资源税提高了用水效率吗？：来自河北的经验证据[J]. 税务研究，(8)：36-42.〔YANG D Q, ZHAO L, YANG D D, 2020. On improvement of water-use efficiency by the water resources tax: based on the empirical evidence from Hebei province[J]. Taxation Research, (8): 36-42.〕

尹庆民，朱康宁，2020. 基于EBM模型的长江经济带工业用水效率时空差异及影响因素分析[J]. 中国环境管理，12(6)：103-109.〔YIN Q M, ZHU K N, 2020. Analysis on the spatial and temporal differences and influencing factors of industrial water efficiency in the yangtze river economic belt based on EBM model[J]. Chinese Journal of Environmental Management, 12(6): 103-109.〕

赵爱武，杜建国，关洪军，2016. 环境税情景下企业环境技术创新模拟[J]. 管理科学，29(1)：40-52.〔ZHAO A W, DU J G, GUAN H J, 2016. Simulation of enterprise environmental technology innovation given the context of environmental tax[J]. Journal of Management Science, 29(1): 40-52.〕

赵艾凤，张予潇，2021. 水资源税对用水量和用水效率的影响研析：以水资源税试点扩围为准自然实验[J]. 税务研究，(2)：35-41.〔ZHAO A F, ZHANG Y X, 2021. On the impacts of water resource tax on water use and water-use efficiency: further roll-out of water resource tax as a quasi-natural experiment[J]. Taxation Research, (2): 35-41.〕

张宝，2020. 水资源税的目的探究与制度完善[J]. 税务研究，(8)：43-48.〔ZHANG B, 2020. Purpose exploration and system improvement of water resources tax[J]. Taxation Research, (8): 43-48.〕

朱智洺，郭伶俐，2021. 灰水足迹测度下长三角地区水质与经济发展关系[J]. 资源与产业，23(1)：1-9.〔ZHU Z M, GUO L L, 2021. Relation of water quality and economic growth in Yangtze river delta region under grey water footprint measurement[J]. Resources & Industries, 23 (1): 1-9.〕

国家统计局，2019. 中国统计年鉴（2019）[M]. 北京：中国统计出版社.

中华人民共和国水利部，2020. 2019中国水资源公报[M]. 北京：中国水利水电出版社.

KARYDAS C, ZHANG L, 2017. Green tax reform, endogenous innovation and the growth dividend[J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 97: 158-181.

HONG I, 2015. Potential welfare loss from using imperfect environmental taxes[J]. Environmental and Resource Economics Review, 24(1): 1-53.

HIMABINDU V, BHRAMARA P, 2016. Pollution control and energy advanced technologies[J]. Environmental Science & Pollution Research, 23(10): 9249-9250.

ZHUQ, SARKIS J, LAI K H, 2013. Institutional-based antecedents and performance outcomes of intemal and external green supply chain management practices[J]. Journal of Purchasing & Supply Management, 19(2): 106-117.

[1]	林向义, 牛艺, 罗洪云, 等. 黑龙江省工业企业能源效率测算及区域差异研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2021, 23(2): 39-47.
[2]	谷春燕，杨敏超. 基于作业动因的工业企业质量成本核算研究——以×锅炉制造企业为例[J]. 资源与产业, 2019, 21(3): 75-82.
[3]	朱晓婷，彭毅. . 汶川地震后四川省工业产业结构变化研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2017, 19(6): 44-48.