地方政府行为对工业能源环境效率的影响——以“一带一路”沿线省市区为例

doi:10.13776/j.cnki.resourcesindustries.20230825.001

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 我国工业发展过程中能源消费总量大，环境污染较为严重，能源使用效率有待提高。以2010—2020“一带一路”沿线省市区工业为研究对象，结合内生增长理论和高质量发展的现实要求，构建全局非径向方向距离函数（global non-radial directional distance function，GNDDF），测算“一带一路”沿线省市区工业能源环境效率。基于面板Tobit模型对工业能源环境效率与地方政府经济干预、地方政府经济竞争、地方政府创新偏向和地方政府环保偏向之间的内在联系展开研究，探讨不同地方政府行为对能源环境效率的影响。研究结果表明：工业能源环境效率呈现“海上丝绸之路＞沿线平均水平＞丝绸之路经济带”的次序分布；各支线工业能源环境效率依“东南线＞西南线＞东北线＞平均水平＞西北线”的次序分布；地方政府经济干预和经济竞争对工业能源环境效率会产生负面影响，地方政府创新偏向和环保偏向的提高有利于促进工业能源环境效率；当地方政府经济干预强度下降时，地方政府经济竞争和地方政府环保偏向对工业能源环境效率的影响显著由负转为正，地方政府创新偏向对工业能源环境效率的作用会增强但不显著。总体来看，推进简政放权、优化地方政府的服务职能有利于提高工业能源环境效率。

关键词:

“一带一路”, 地方政府行为, 工业能源环境效率, 非径向方向距离

Abstract:

China has a big energy consumption during industrialization, leading to severe environmental pollution, which requires an improving energy use efficiency. This paper, based on “the Belt and Road” provinces/cities ‘ 2010 to 2020 industries, uses intrinsic growth theory and quality development demand to establish a global non-radial directional distance function (GNDDF), which is employed to estimate the industrial energy environmental efficiency along “the Belt and Road” provinces/cities. Tobit model is applied to study the inner connection of industrial energy environmental efficiency and local governmental interventions, local governmental economic competition, local governmental preference on innovation and on environmental protection, and to discuss the impacts of governmental behaviors on industrial energy environmental efficiency. Industrial energy environmental efficiency shows a distribution order of “oceanic silk road>average>the silk road economic zone”, and an order of “southeast line>southwest line>northeast line>average>northwest line” on the side lines. Local governmental economic interventions and economic competition adversely affect industrial energy environmental efficiency, but their preference on innovation and environmental protection work positively. When their interventions are decreasing in intensity, the impacts will largely switch from negative to positive, increasingly but not outstandingly. This paper presents suggestions on simplifying governance, empowering, optimizing local governmental functions for increasing industrial energy environmental efficiency.

Key words:

“the Belt and Road”, local governmental behaviors, industrial energy environmental efficiency, GNDDF

中图分类号:

F206

杨恺钧, 王文轩. 地方政府行为对工业能源环境效率的影响——以“一带一路”沿线省市区为例[J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(6): 91-104.

YANG Kaijun, WANG Wenxuan.

IMPACTS OF LOCAL GOVERNMENTAL BEHAVIORS ON INDUSTRIAL ENERGY ENVIRONMENTAL EFFICIENCY ALONG“THE BELT AND ROAD” PROVINCES/CITIES [J]. Resources & Industries, 2023, 25(6): 91-104.

参考文献

陈书伟, 韩丽, 2022.政府创新补贴促进了企业绿色技术创新水平吗?：基于信号传递的视角[J].资源与产业, 24（5）: 98-107.〔CHEN S W, HAN L, 2022.Does governmental allowance promote enterprises‘green technical innovation level viewing from information transmission?[J].Resources & Industries, 24（5）: 98-107.〕

陈峥, 2017.能源禀赋、政府干预与中国能源效率研究[D].武汉: 中南财经政法大学.〔CHEN Z, 2017.Energy resource endowment, government intervention and analysis on China energy efficiency[D].Wuhan: Zhongnan University of Economics and Law.〕

东童童, 2017.全要素工业能源效率与雾霾污染的交互影响: 以长江经济带为例[J].城市问题（11）: 87-95.〔DONG T T, 2017.Interactive effect between total-factor industrial energy efficiency and haze pollution: taking the Yangtze River Economic Belt for example[J].Urban Problems（11）: 87-95.〕

杜克锐, 鄢哲明, 杨志明, 2018.能源和环境绩效评价方法的最新研究进展[J].环境经济研究, 3（1）: 113-138.〔DU K R, YAN Z M, YANG Z M, 2018.Progress of evaluation methods on energy and environmental performance[J].Journal of Environmental Economics,3（1）: 113-138.〕

高达, 李格, 2022.政府合作与城市群能源效率: 基于长三角城市经济协调会的准自然实验[J].软科学, 36（2）: 78-85.〔GAO D, LI G, 2022.Government cooperation and energy efficiency in urban agglomeration: quasi-natural experiment based on the Yangtze River delta urban economic coordination committee[J].Soft Science, 36（2）: 78-85.〕

高明, 2016.基于DDF函数和Meta-frontier模型的中国省际能源效率研究[J].统计与决策（1）: 146-150.

惠炜, 韩先锋, 2016.生产性服务业集聚促进了地区劳动生产率吗?[J].数量经济技术经济研究, 33（10）: 37-56.〔HUI W, HAN X F, 2016.Does the agglomeration of producer services promote the regional labor productivity?[J].Journal of Quantitative & Technological Economics, 33（10）: 37-56.〕

江洪, 李金萍, 李秋雁, 2022.政府发展性支出、产业集聚与绿色能源效率[J].技术经济, 41（1）: 53-65.〔JIANG H, LI J P, LI Q Y, 2022.Government development expenditures, industrial agglomeration, and green energy efficiency [J].Journal of TechnologyEconomics, 41（1）: 53-65.〕

李根, 刘家国, 李天琦, 2019.考虑非期望产出的制造业能源生态效率地区差异研究: 基于SBM和Tobit模型的两阶段分析[J].中国管理科学, 27（11）: 76-87.〔LI G, LIU J G, LI T Q, 2019.Regional differences of energy eco-efficiency in manufacturing industry under consideration of undesirable outputs based on the SBM-Tobit Two-stage Model[J].Chinese Journal of Management Science, 27（11）: 76-87.〕

李颖, 徐小峰, 郑越, 2019.环境规制强度对中国工业全要素能源效率的影响: 基于2003—2016年30省域面板数据的实证研究[J].管理评论, 31（12）: 40-48.〔LI Y, XU X F, ZHENG Y, 2019.An empirical study of environmental regulation impact on China ‘s industrial total factor energy efficiency: based on the data of 30 provinces from 2003 to 2016[J].Management Review, 31（12）: 40-48.〕

李政, 杨思莹, 2018.财政分权、政府创新偏好与区域创新效率[J].管理世界, 34（12）: 29-42, 110, 193-194.〔LI Z, YANG S Y, 2018.Fiscal decentralization, government innovation preferences, and regional innovation efficiency[J].Journal of Management World, 34（12）: 29-42, 110, 193-194.〕

林伯强, 刘泓汛, 2015.对外贸易是否有利于提高能源环境效率: 以中国工业行业为例[J].经济研究（9）: 127-141.〔LIN B Q, LIU H X, 2015.Do energy and environment efficiency benefit from foreign trade？: the case of China ‘s industrial sectors[J].Economic Research Journal（9）: 127-141.〕

刘儒, 卫离东, 2022.地方政府竞争、产业集聚与区域绿色发展效率: 基于空间关联与溢出视角的分析[J].经济问题探索（1）: 79-91.〔LIU R, WEI L D, 2022.Local government competition, industrial agglomeration and regional green development efficiency: analysis based on spatial correlation and spillover perspective[J].Inquiry into Economic Issues（1）: 79-91.〕

刘那日苏, 栗昕彤, 2022.政府干预、基础设施与绿色全要素生产率: 来自黄河流域的经验证据[J].科技和产业, 22（9）: 61-66.〔LIU N R S, LI X T, 2022.Government intervention, transportation infrastructure and total factor productivity: based on the analysis of urban data in the Yellow River basin[J].Science Technology and Industry, 22 （9）: 61-66.〕

马流星, 韦邦荣, 2021.财政分权、地方政府竞争与地区全要素生产率[J].河南工程学院学报（社会科学版）, 36（1）: 1-8.〔MA L X, WEI B R, 2021.Fiscal decentralization, local government competition and regional total factor productivity[J].Journal of Henan University of Engineering （Social Sciences Edition）, 36（1）: 1-8.〕

马骏, 伍琳玲, 卢玉钦, 2022.碳排放视域下长江经济带绿色发展效率测度及影响因素研究[J].资源与产业, 24（3）: 71-80.〔MA J, WU L L, LU Y Q, 2022.Green development efficiency measurement and factors of Yangtze River economic zone under perspective of carbon emission[J].Resources & Industries, 24（3）: 71-80.〕

穆献中, 周文韬, 胡广文, 2022.不同类型环境规制对全要素能源效率的影响[J].北京理工大学学报（社会科学版）, 24（3）: 56-74.〔MU X Z, ZHOU W T, HU G W, 2022. Impacts of different types of environmental regulations ‘ on total factor energy efficiency of China[J].Journal of Beijing Institute of Technology （Social Sciences Edition）, 24（3）: 56-74.〕

聂雷, 任建辉, 刘秀丽, 等, 2021.金融深化、政府干预与绿色全要素生产率: 来自中国10个城市群的经验证据[J].软科学, 35（1）: 50-55.〔NIE L, REN J H, LIU X L, et al, 2021.Financial deepening, government intervention and green total factor productivity: empirical evidence from 10 urban agglomerations in China[J].Soft Science, 35（1）: 50-55.〕

钱敏, 金小莉, 2021.“一带一路”沿线省份FDI、环境规制对能源利用效率的影响研究[J].资源与产业, 23（6）: 79-85.〔QIAN M, JIN X L, 2021. Impacts of FDI and environmental regulations on energy utilization efficiency along the “Belt and Road” provinces[J].Resources & Industries, 23（6）: 79-85.〕

冉启英, 于海燕, 2015.有无环境约束下西部地区全要素能源效率及其影响因素研究[J].新疆大学学报（哲学·人文社会科学版）, 43（3）: 15-22.〔RAN Q Y, YU H Y, 2015.Total factor energy efficiency and the influencing factors in western region with or without environmental restrictions[J].Journal of Xinjiang University （Philosophy, Humanities & Social Science）, 43（3）: 15-22.〕

宋马林, 陶伟良, 翁世梅, 2021.区域产业升级、政府创新支持与能源生态效率的动态关系研究: 淮河生态经济带的实证分析[J].中国地质大学学报（社会科学版）, 21（4）: 119-132.〔SONG M L, TAO W L, WENG S M, 2021. Research on the dynamic relationship between regional industrial upgrade, government innovation support and energy eco-efficiency: an empirical study of the Huaihe River Eco-economic Belt[J].Journal of China University of Geosciences （Social Sciences Edition）, 21（4）: 119-132.〕

宋晓玲, 李金叶, 2022.产业协同集聚、地方政府竞争与制造业绿色发展[J].经济经纬, 39（4）: 86-96.〔SONG X L, LI J Y, 2022. Industrial collaborative agglomeration, local government competition and green development of manufacturing industry[J].Economic Survey, 39（4）: 86-96.〕

孙国锋, 张婵, 2017.财政分权、地方政府竞争与生态效率: 基于空间SDM模型的实证研究[J].产业经济评论（山东大学）, 16（2）: 145-167.〔SUN G F, ZHANG C, 2017.Impact of fiscal decentralization and local government competition on eco-efficiency: an empirical study based on spatial SDM model[J].Review of Industrial Economics, 16 （2）: 145-167.〕

田红宇, 祝志勇, 胡晓清, 2019.财政分权、地方政府竞争与区域科技创新效率[J].中国科技论坛（11）: 103-112.〔TIAN H Y, ZHU Z Y, HU X Q, 2019.Fiscal decentralization, local government competition and and regional technological innovation efficiency[J].Forum on Science and Technology in China（11）: 103-112.〕

汪东芳, 曹建华, 2019.互联网发展对中国全要素能源效率的影响及网络效应研究[J].中国人口·资源与环境, 29（1）: 86-95.〔WANG D F, CAO J H, 2019.The impact of internet development on China ‘s total factor energy efficiency and its network effects[J].China Population, Resources and Environment, 29（1）: 86-95.〕

吴延瑞, 2008.生产率对中国经济增长的贡献: 新的估计[J].经济学（季刊）, 7（3）: 827-842.〔WU Y R, 2008.The role of productivity in China ‘s growth: new estimates[J].China Economic Quarterly, 7（3）: 827-842.〕

吴勋, 白蕾, 2019.财政分权、地方政府行为与雾霾污染: 基于73个城市PM2.5浓度的实证研究[J].经济问题（3）: 23-31.〔WU X, BAI L, 2019.Fiscal decentralization, local government behavior and haze pollution: analysis based on PM2.5 concentration in 73 cities[J].On Economic Problems（3）: 23-31.〕

徐敏, 周婷婷, 王凌, 等, 2022.政府支持对高技术产业绿色创新效率的影响研究[J].资源与产业, 24（6）: 64-74.〔XU M, ZHOU T T, WANG L, et al, 2022.Impacts of governmental supports on green innovative efficiency of high-tech industries[J].Resources & Industries, 24 （6）: 64-74.〕

杨航, 2016.出口技术复杂度与工业能源效率[D].广州: 暨南大学.〔YANG H, 2016.Export sophistication and industrial energy efficiency: from a perspective of government intervention[D].Guangzhou: Jinan University.〕

杨慧慧, 2019.环境管制方式对能源效率影响的差异性: 基于内生视角下的PVAR方法的分析[J].商业研究（7）: 67-76.〔YANG H H, 2019. Differences of environmental control modes on energy efficiency: PVAR method based on endogenous perspective[J].Commercial Research（7）: 67-76.〕

杨恺钧, 闵崇智, 2019.高质量发展要求下工业绿色全要素能源效率: 基于中国“一带一路”沿线省份的实证[J].管理现代化, 39（4）: 114-117.〔YANG K J, MIN C Z, 2019.Research on industrial green total factor energy efficiency in the requirements of high quality development: based on the China ‘s provinces along the“The Belt and Road Initiative”[J].Modernization of Management, 39（4）: 114-117.〕

杨志江, 朱桂龙, 2017.技术创新、环境规制与能源效率: 基于中国省际面板数据的实证检验[J].研究与发展管理, 29（4）: 23-32.〔YANG Z J, ZHU G L, 2017.Technology innovation, environmental regulation and energy efficiency: an empirical study based on Chinese provincial panel data[J].R&D Management, 29（4）: 23-32.〕

叶红雨, 李奕杰, 2022.环境规制、偏向性技术进步与能源效率[J].华东经济管理, 36（4）: 97-106.〔YE H Y, LI Y J, 2022.Environmental regulation, directed technical change and energy efficiency[J].East China Economic Management, 36（4）: 97-106.〕

岳立, 杨玉春, 江铃峰, 2018.“丝绸之路经济带”绿色全要素能源效率的地区差异及影响因素研究: 基于Global Malmquist-Luenberger指数的实证分析[J].兰州大学学报（社会科学版）, 46（6）: 158-166.〔YUE L, YANG Y C, JIANG L F, 2018. Regional differences and influential factors of total factor green energy efficiency in the Silk Road Economic Belt: an empirical analysis based on the Global Malmquist-Luenberger index[J].Journal of Lanzhou University（Social Sciences）, 46 （6）: 158-166.〕

张成芬, 朱晓宇, 2022.数字金融对高技术产业创新效率的影响研究[J].管理现代化, 42（5）: 105-112.〔ZHANG C F, ZHU X Y, 2022.Research on the impact of digital finance on innovation efficiency of high-tech industry[J].Modernization of Management,42（5）: 105-112.〕

张宵, 葛玉辉, 2023.创新生态系统视域下高新技术产业创新效率评价及影响因素: 基于DEA-Tobit模型的实证研究[J].科学与管理,43（1）: 27-35.〔ZHANG X, GE Y H, 2023.Evaluation and influencing factors of innovation efficiency of high-tech industry from the perspective of innovation ecosystem: empirical research based on DEA-Tobit model[J].Science and Management, 43（1）: 27-35.〕

张在旭, 黄卓琳, 2020.中国省际绿色技术创新效率测度及影响因素研究[J].资源与产业, 22（6）: 1-8.〔ZHANG Z X, HUANG Z L, 2020.Measurement and factors of China ‘s provincial green technical innovation efficiency[J].Resources & Industries, 22 （6）: 1-8.〕

张治栋, 廖常文, 2019.全要素生产率与经济高质量发展: 基于政府干预视角[J].软科学, 33（12）: 29-35.〔ZHANG Z D, LIAO C W, 2019.Total factor productivity and high-quality economic development: an empirical research based on the perspective of government intervention[J].Soft Science, 33（12）: 29-35.〕

周凌燕, 刘静宜, 2021.环境规制下政府科技投入对工业企业绿色发展影响[J].工业技术经济, 40（1）: 128-133.〔ZHOU L Y, LIU J Y, 2021.The impact of government science and technology input on industrial green development under environmental regulation[J].Journal of Industrial Technological Economics, 40（1）: 128-133.〕

周敏, 王腾, 严良, 等, 2019.财政分权、经济竞争对中国能源生态效率影响异质性研究[J].资源科学, 41（3）: 532-545.〔ZHOU M, WANG T, YAN L, et al, 2019.Heterogeneity in the influence of fiscal decentralization and economic competition on China ‘s energy ecological efficiency[J].Resources Science, 41（3）: 532-545.〕

OH D H, 2010.A global Malmquist-Luenberger productivity index[J].Journal of Productivity Analysis, 34（3）: 183-197.

ZHANG N, KONG F B, CHOI Y, et al, 2014.The effect of size-control policy on unified energy and carbon efficiency for Chinese fossil fuel power plants[J].Energy Policy, 70（14）: 193-200.