VISUAL ANALYSIS OF GREEN TECHNICAL
INNOVATION OF GLOBAL ENTERPRISES BASED ON CITESPACE

doi:10.13776/j.cnki.resourcesindustries.20240306.003

Abstract

Abstract: This paper reviews green innovative achievements of global enterprises, and finds out China's blank areas, and explores its developing trend, providing theoretical references for green technical innovation system. Based on WOS and CNKI database (1993-2022), 861 and 509 pieces of paper are selected respectively through advanced query and manual screening. Visual analysis tool CiteSpace is used to analyse research characteristics from publishing years, regions, key words. The major research region is China and European and American countries with a rising paper counts and high centrality. China's highquality references have been surging in recent five years, mainly on empirical study. European and American countries are closely cooperating with a better global view. Domestic research has been basically shaped, being steadily rising stage, processoriented, focusing on factors and mechanism. It produces some Chinese-featured outputs under China-s special system. Foreign research system is sounder, results-oriented, focusing on green innovative performance and its values, including economic, social and ecological values. Green technical innovation is a strategy. Foreign research has undergone “fuzzy period”, “diversified developing period” and “blooming developing period”. This paper presents suggestions on focusing on value- and market-oriented perspectives, on diversifying expansion, on combination with ecology to explore their inner connection of green technology and ecological protection, and on detailed mechanism to find the obstacles against green innovation. This paper contributes to Chinese-featured green technological innovation.

Key words:

enterprise, green technological innovation; CiteSpace, bibliometrics, knowledge graph

摘要： 系统梳理国内外企业绿色创新成果，对比找出国内研究的空白，同时探索企业主体进行绿色技术创新的发展趋势，为进一步完善市场导向的绿色技术创新体系提供理论依据。基于 WOS 和 CNKI 数据库资源（1993—2022年)，经高级检索和人工筛选后分别得到861和509篇相关文献，运用文献可视化计量分析工具 CiteSpace，从文献时间分布、发文区域、关键词共现、关键词时间线和突现词等方面，分析国内外研究领域特点。研究表明：1）该主题的研究区域主要是中国和欧美国家，发文数量呈逐年递增趋势，且中心性高。其中中国高质量文献数量在近5年间增长较快，以实证研究为主；欧美国家间的研究合作密切，全球视角明显。2）国内研究初具框架，但尚未形成完整体系，正处于稳步上升、持续趋热阶段。国内研究关注过程导向，主要研究企业绿色技术创新的影响因素及实现机理，同时立足于本国独特的制度环境，产出了一些富有中国特色的成果。3）国外研究体系更为健全，注重结果导向，即关注企业绿色创新的“绩效”，聚焦绿色技术创新的价值，包括经济价值、社会舆论价值、生态价值等，同时将企业绿色技术创新上升到了战略视角。国外研究大致经历了“模糊期”“多元发展期”和“蓬勃发展期”3个阶段。由此，对未来发展做出预测，提出以下建议：未来研究应聚焦于企业绿色技术创新的价值导向和市场导向；“企业绿色技术创新”应向多元学科拓展，如与生态学结合，从理论视角探索绿色技术与生态保护的内在联系；未来要细化机制研究，基于实际，探索阻碍企业开展绿色创新的问题，提出更多具有实践意义的方法论。本文为中国“企业绿色技术创新”体系的丰富和发展，为走出一条有中国特色的绿色技术自主创新之路做出贡献。

关键词: 企业, 绿色技术创新, CiteSpace, 文献计量学, 知识图谱

CLC Number:

F2731

YUAN Ruhua, WANG Yaping, JIA Kuiyuan.

VISUAL ANALYSIS OF GREEN TECHNICAL INNOVATION OF GLOBAL ENTERPRISES BASED ON CITESPACE [J]. Resources & Industries, 2024, 26(2): 151-163.

袁汝华, 王雅平, 贾葵源.

基于CiteSpace的国内外企业绿色技术创新研究可视分析

[J]. 资源与产业, 2024, 26(2): 151-163.

References

毕奕侃, 韩毅, 2020. 关键词时间分布特征视角下的研究前沿探测研究[J]. 西华大学学报（哲学社会科学版）, 39(2): 105-114.〔BI Y K, HAN Y, 2020. Studies on research front detection under the context of time distribution characteristics of key words[J]. Journal of Xihua University(Philosophy & Social Sciences), 39(2): 105-114.〕

曹康康, 2022. 探索绿色技术创新的哲学意境[N]. 中国社会科学报, 2022-10-25(06).〔CAO K K, 2022. Exploring the philosophical context of green technology innovation[N]. Social Sciences in China, 2022-10-25(06).〕

陈恒, 彭程, 郭爽, 等, 2022. 基于复杂市场网络绿色技术创新扩散的两阶段演化分析[J]. 中国管理科学(1): 1-11.〔CHEN H, PENG C, GUO S, et al., 2022. Two-stage evolution analysis of green technology innovation diffusion based on complex market network[J]. Chinese Journal of Management Science (1): 1-11.〕

陈悦, 陈超美, 刘则渊, 等, 2015. CiteSpace知识图谱的方法论功能[J]. 科学学研究, 33(2): 242-253.〔CHEN Y, CHEN C M, LIU Z Y, et al., 2015. The methodology function of CiteSpace mapping knowledge domains[J]. Studies in Science of Science, 33(2): 242-253.〕

陈书伟, 韩丽, 2022. 政府创新补贴促进了企业绿色技术创新水平吗?: 基于信号传递的视角[J]. 资源与产业, 24(5): 98-107. 〔CHEN S W, HAN L, 2022. Does governmental allowance promote enterprises’ green technical innovation level viewing from information transmission?[J]. Resources & Industries, 24(5): 98-107.〕

崔小杰, 2023. 碳排放权交易政策、技术变革与钢铁企业绿色转型[J/OL]. 财会通讯: 1-6[2023-08-12]. https://doi. org/10. 16144/j. cnki. issn1002-8072. 20230614. 001.〔CUI X J, 2023. Carbon emission trading policies, technological changes and green transformation of iron and steel enterprises[J/OL]. Communication of Finance and Accounting:1-6[2023-08-12]. https://doi. org/10. 16144/j. cnki. issn1002-8072. 20230614. 001.〕

董景荣, 张文卿, 陈宇科, 2021. 环境规制工具、政府支持对绿色技术创新的影响研究[J]. 产业经济研究(3): 1-16.〔DONG J R, ZHANG W Q, CHEN Y K, 2021. The impact of environmental regulation tools and government support on green technological innovation[J]. Industrial Economics Research (3): 1-16.〕

李亚兵, 夏月, 赵振, 2023. 高管绿色认知对重污染行业企业绩效的影响: 一个有调节的中介效应模型[J]. 科技进步与对策, 40(7): 113-123.〔LI Y B, XIA Y, ZHAO Z, 2023. The relationship between executives’ green perception and firm performance in heavy pollution industries: a moderated mediating effect model[J]. Science & Technology Progress and Policy, 40(7): 113-123.〕

刘勇, 2011. 绿色技术创新与传统意义技术创新辨析[J]. 工业技术经济, 30(12): 55-60.〔LIU Y, 2011. Differentiating between the environmental sound technological innovation and innovation in the traditional meaning[J]. Journal of Industrial Technological Economics, 30(12): 55-60.〕

乔菲, 文雯, 冯晓晴, 2022. “国家队”持股能促进企业绿色创新吗？: 重污染行业的异质性分析[J]. 科技进步与对策, 39(22): 92-102. 〔QIAO F, WEN W, FENG X Q, 2022. Can “national team” ownership promote corporate green innovation?: the heterogeneity analysis of heavily-polluted industry[J]. Science & Technology Progress and Policy, 39(22): 92-102.〕

秦阿宁, 孙玉玲, 王燕鹏, 等, 2021. 碳中和背景下的国际绿色技术发展态势分析[J]. 世界科技研究与发展, 43(4): 385-402. 〔QIN A N, SUN Y L, WANG Y P, et al. , 2021. Analysis on the development trend of international green technology under the background of carbon neutrality[J]. World Sci-Tech R & D, 43(4): 385-402.〕

苏屹, 魏仕鹏, 2022. 基于三方博弈的绿色技术创新演化研究[J]. 运筹与管理, 31(6): 40-47.〔SU Y, WEI S P, 2022. Evolution of green technology innovation based on the tripartite game[J]. Operations Research and Management Science, 31(6): 40-47.〕

王晶华, 陈祺琪, 顾金科, 2022. 我国农业科技创新研究热点及演进态势: 基于CiteSpace的可视化分析[J]. 科技管理研究, 42(22): 8-16.〔WANG J H, CHEN Q Q, GU J K, 2022. Research hot spots and evolution trend of agricultural science and technology innovation in China: a visual analysis based on CiteSpace[J]. Science and Technology Management Research, 42(22): 8-16.〕

韦庆明, 赵欣欣, 冯馨, 等, 2022. 环境规制、绿色创新与产业结构升级: 基于省际面板数据的空间杜宾模型分析[J]. 资源与产业, 24(6): 54-63.〔WEI Q M, ZHAO X X, FENG X, et al., 2022. Environmental regulation, green innovation and industrial structure upgrading: spatial Dubin model analysis based on provincial panel data[J] . Resources & Industries, 24(6): 54-63.〕

谢家平, 孔令丞, 梁玲, 2022. 数字时代市场导向下中国绿色技术创新体系构建研究[J]. 当代经济管理, 44(12):18-26.〔XIE J P, KONG L C, LIANG L, 2022. Construction of China’s green technology innovation system based on market orientation in the digital age[J]. Contemporary Economic Management, 44(12): 18-26.〕

谢宜章, 杨帆, 2023. 环境规制、研发投入与先进制造业绿色技术创新[J]. 财经理论与实践, 44(4): 129-136.〔XIE Y Z, YANG F, 2023. Environmental regulation, R&D investment and green technology innovation of advanced manufacturing industry[J]. The Theory and Practice of Finance and Economics, 44(4): 129-136.〕

阳镇, 陈劲, 凌鸿程, 2022. 媒体关注、环境政策不确定性与企业绿色技术创新: 来自中国A股上市公司的经验证据[J]. 管理工程学报, 37(4): 1-15.〔YANG Z, CHEN J, LING H C, 2022. Media attention, environmental policy uncertainty and firm’s green technology: empirical evidence from Chinese A-share listed firms[J]. Journal of Industrial Engineering and Engineering Management, 37(4): 1-15.〕

杨成玉, 2021. 欧盟绿色发展的实践与挑战: 基于碳中和视域下的分析[J]. 德国研究, 36(3): 79-97, 154-155.〔YANG C Y, 2021. Practices and challenges of green development in the European Union: an analysis based on a carbon neutral perspective[J]. Germany Studies, 36(3): 79-97, 154-155.〕

杨东, 柴慧敏, 2015. 企业绿色技术创新的驱动因素及其绩效影响研究综述[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 25(S2):132-136.〔YANG D, CHAI H M, 2015. A review of driving factors of green technology innovation and its effect on firm’s performance[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 25(S2): 132-136.〕

张英健, 2022. 打造绿色技术创新新引擎: 《关于进一步完善市场导向的绿色技术创新体系实施方案（2023—2025年）》政策解读之二[EB/OL].（2022-12-30）[2023-01-24]. https://baijiahao. baidu. com/s?id=1753601746515576360&wfr=spider&for=pc.

朱泽钢, 2022. 治理机制对绿色技术创新的驱动作用[J]. 中国软科学(12):125-135.〔ZHU Z G, 2022. Driving effect of governance mechanism on green technology innovation[J]. China Soft Science(12): 125-135.〕

DE JESUS PACHECO D A, TEN CATEN C S, JUNG C F, et al., 2018. Eco-innovation determinants in manufacturing SMEs from emerging markets: systematic literature review and challenges[J]. Journal of Engineering and Technology Management, 48: 44-63.

FERNANDO Y, CHIAPPETTA JABBOUR C J, WAH W X, 2019. Pursuing green growth in technology firms through the connections between environmental innovation and sustainable business performance: does service capability matter? [J]. Resources Conservation and Recycling, 141: 8-20.

JAFFE A M, MYSLIKOVA Z, QI Q, et al., 2023. Green innovation of state-owned oil and gas enterprises in BRICS countries: a review of performance[J]. Climate Policy, 23(9):1167-1181.

KUO T C, SMITH S, 2018. A systematic review of technologies involving eco-innovation for enterprises moving towards sustainability[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 192: 207-220.

PALMER M, TRUONG Y, 2017. The impact of technological green new product introductions on firm profitability[J]. Ecological Economics, 136: 86-93.

XIE X, HUO J, ZOU H, 2019. Green process innovation, green product innovation, and corporate financial performance: a content analysis method[J]. Journal of Business Research, 101: 697-706.

YU F, JIANG D, WANG T, 2022. The impact of green innovation on manufacturing small and medium enterprises corporate social responsibility fulfillment: the moderating role of regional environmental regulation[J]. Corporate Social Responsibility and Environmental Management, 29(3): 712-727.

[1]	SUN Tingting, FAN Chuanhao. VISUALIZED COMPARISON OF DOMESTIC & OVERSEAS GREEN INNOVATION RESEARCH BASED ON CITESAPCE DATA [J]. Resources & Industries, 2021, 23(6): 52-63.
[2]	ZHAO Yiran, GAO Xiangyun. RESEARCH ADVANCES AND OUTLOOK OF STRATEGIC COBALT RESOURCE BASED ON REFERENCES STUDY [J]. Resources & Industries, 2020, 22(1): 41-51.
[3]	Tang Yongwei, Qin He, Chen Huailu.. BIBLIOMETRICS STUDY ON ADVANCES OF CHINA'S URBANTRANSFORMATION DURING 2000 TO 2012 [J]. Resources & Industries, 2014, 16(5): 13-22.