基于质性分析的水敏感型企业水信息披露要素及特征研究——以国际矿业企业为例

doi:10.13776/j.cnki.resourcesindustries.20230908.002

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

世界范围内的水资源紧张现象使水敏感型企业的水信息披露问题成为关注热点，水信息披露的要素和特征成为企业向政府、社会及利益相关者传递其水资源运营状况、社会责任履行、可持续发展战略实施的重要途径。以2021年全球40强矿业企业的可持续发展报告中披露的水资源相关文本为研究样本，运用质性分析法通过NVivo软件对企业披露的水信息内容进行词频统计、编码归纳、矩阵和聚类分析，探究以矿业企业为代表的水敏感型企业水信息披露的特征及要素框架。结果表明：1）企业水信息披露主要涉及3个范畴，涵盖15个主题，分别是企业水资源管理、利益相关者责任和环境可持续发展；2）企业水资源及其运营活动是信息披露的关键内容，但对间接利益相关者的水信息需求重视程度不够；3）国内外企业对水管理合规性、战略和绩效、员工参与和对外合作的关注度存在显著差异。研究结论为水敏感型企业进一步提高水信息披露标准和质量提供了一定的理论依据和发展建议。

关键词: 质性分析, 水信息披露, 水敏感型企业, 矿业企业, NVivo编码

Abstract: Water resource shortage worldwide makes water information disclosure of water-sensitive firms a hot point. Elements and features of water information disclosure are a vital means for firms to transmit water resource operation, social responsibilities and sustainable development strategy to governments, society and stakeholders. This paper, based in 2021 water information disclosure from global top 40 mining firms ‘ sustainable development reports, uses qualitative method via NVivo software to study key words frequency, coding classification, matrix and clustering of firms ‘ water information disclosure, and to analyze it elements and features of water-sensitive mining firms. Firm ‘s water information disclosure mainly covers 3 aspects, 15 topics, regarding water resource management, stakeholders and environmentally sustainable development. Information disclosure focuses on firm ‘s water resource and operation, little on indirect stakeholders ‘ demands. Global firms ‘ attention on water management compliance, strategy and performance, employee involvement and external cooperation varies. This study presents theoretical reference and suggestions for water-sensitive firms to further improve water information standards and quality.

Key words: qualitative analysis, water information disclosure, water-sensitive firms, mining firms; NVivo coding

中图分类号:

F205

李青, 王菲.

基于质性分析的水敏感型企业水信息披露要素及特征研究——以国际矿业企业为例 [J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(5): 122-133.

LI Qing, WANG Fei.

CASE STUDY ON GLOBAL MINING: WATER INFORMATION DISCLOSURE ELEMENTS AND FEATURES OF WATERSENSITIVE FIRMS BASED ON QUALITATIVE ANALYSIS [J]. Resources & Industries, 2023, 25(5): 122-133.

参考文献

樊晓霞, 2022. 水会计信息披露对绿色创新影响的研究[D]. 太原：太原理工大学.〔FAN X X, 2022. Research on the impact of water accounting information disclosure on green innovation[D]. Taiyuan：Taiyuan University of Technology.〕

郭华, 甘巧林, 2011. 乡村旅游社区居民社会排斥的多维度感知：江西婺源李坑村案例的质化研究[J]. 旅游学刊, 26(8): 87-94.〔GUO H, GAN Q L, 2011. Multi-dimensional perception of social exclusion of residents in rural tourism communities: a qualitative study on the case of Likeng Village, Wuyuan, Jiangxi[J]. Tourism Journal, 26(8): 87-94.〕

胡萍, 2012. 质性分析工具的比较与应用研究[D]. 长沙：湖南师范大学.〔HU P, 2012. Comparative and applied research of qualitative analysis tools[D]. Changsha：Hunan Normal University.〕

李世辉, 程宸, 王淑窈, 等, 2020. 水信息披露、机构投资者与股价同步性[J]. 财经理论与实, 41(6): 57-63.〔LI S H, CHENG H, WANG S J, et al, 2020. Water information disclosure, institutional investors and stock price synchronicity[J]. Finance Theory & Practice, 41(6): 57-63.〕

李世辉, 何绍丽, 贺逸萱, 2018. 企业水信息披露研究综述[J]. 财会通讯(19): 41-44.〔LI S H, HE S L, HE Y X, 2018. A review of enterprise water information disclosure[J]. Finance and Accounting Newsletter (19): 41-44.〕

李世辉, 刘一洁, 雷新途, 2021. “水十条”与企业水信息披露水平：基于高水敏感性行业的准自然实验[J]. 中南大学学报(社会科学版), 27(3): 88-99.〔LI S H, LIU Y J, LEI X T, 2021. “Water Ten Rules” and the level of enterprise water information disclosure: a quasi-natural experiment based on high water sensitivity industry[J]. Journal of Central South University (Social Science Edition), 27(3): 88-99.〕

钱明, 徐光华, 沈弋, 2016. 社会责任信息披露、会计稳健性与融资约束: 基于产权异质性的视角[J]. 会计研究 (5): 9-17, 95.〔QIAN M, XU G H, SHEN Y, 2016.Social responsibility information disclosure, accounting soundness and financing constraints: based on the perspective of property rights heterogeneity[J]. Accounting Research (5): 9-17, 95.〕

唐斌, 席振华, 曾镇坚, 2021. 农村基本公共服务均等化政策的演进逻辑及其实践工具：基于“中央一号文件”的质性分析[J]. 甘肃行政学院学报 (3): 24-33, 125.〔TANG B, XI Z H, ZENG Z J, 2021. The evolutionary logic and practical tools of rural basic public service equalization policy: a qualitative analysis based on the “Central Document No.1”[J]. Journal of Gansu Institute of Administration (3): 24-33, 125.〕

王峥, 许超, 2021. 23省“健康规划纲要”中的老龄政策分析：健康老龄化视域下的NVivo质性研究[J].中国卫生政策研究, 14(12): 8-15.〔WANG Z, XU C, 2021. Analysis of aging policy in the “Health Planning Outline” of 23: a qualitative study of NVivo from the perspective of healthy aging[J]. China Health Policy Research, 14(12): 8-15.〕

席岑, 王茗萱, 刘轶芳, 等, 2018. 投资者对上市公司负面环境事件的关注及其市场反应[J]. 环境经济研究, 3(4): 46-70.〔XI C, WANG M X, LIU Y F, et al, 2018. Investors ‘ attention to negative environmental events of listed companies and their market responses[J]. Environmental Economic Research, 3(4): 46-70.〕

徐建玲, 顾浩丰, 周志远, 等, 2020. 水信息披露、媒体关注与企业价值：基于制造业上市公司的实证分析[J]. 新疆财经大学学报 (3): 55-63.〔XU J L, GU H F, ZHOU Z Y, et al, 2020. Water information disclosure, media attention and enterprise value: an empirical analysis based on listed companies in manufacturing[J]. Journal of Xinjiang University of Finance and Economics (3): 55-63.〕

薛锋, 李青青, 户佐安, 2022. 基于NVivo质性分析的研究生导师指导模式构建及综合指导能力评价研究[J]. 黑龙江高教研究, 40(5): 107-114.〔XUE F, LI Q Q, HU Z A, 2022. Construction of graduate tutor guidance model and comprehensive guidance ability evaluation based on NVivo qualitative analysis[J]. Heilongjiang Studies of Higher Education, 40(5): 107-114.〕

曾辉祥, 李世辉, 周志方, 等, 2018. 水资源信息披露、媒体报道与企业风险[J]. 会计研究 (4): 89-96.〔ZENG H X, LI S H, ZHOU Z F, et al. 2018.Water resources information disclosure, media coverage and enterprise risk[J]. Accounting Research (4): 89-96.〕

张倩, 沈菊琴, 孙付华, 等, 2021. 企业水信息披露影响因素实证研究：基于中国化工行业上市企业的数据[J]. 资源与产业, 23(4): 53-62.〔ZHANG Q, SHEN J Q, SUN F H, et al, 2021. An empirical study on the influencing factors of corporate water information disclosure: based on the data of listed companies in China ‘s chemical industry[J]. Resources & Industries, 23(4): 53-62.〕

周志方, 陈佳纯, 曾辉祥, 2019. 产品市场竞争对企业水信息披露的影响研究：基于2010—2016年中国高水敏感性行业的经验证据[J]. 商业经济与管理 (11): 70-86.〔ZHOU Z F, CHEN J C, ZENG H X, 2019. Research on the impact of product market competition on enterprise water information disclosure：based on empirical evidence of China ‘s high water sensitive industry from 2010 to 2016[J]. Business Economics and Management (11): 70-86.〕

周志方, 刘金豪, 曾辉祥, 2020. 水信息披露对企业风险承担水平的影响：来自高水风险行业的证据[J]. 环境经济研究, 5(4): 54-74.〔ZHOU Z F, LIU J H, ZENG H X, 2020. The impact of water information disclosure on corporate risk-taking level: Evidence from high water risk industries[J]. Environmental Economic Research, 5(4): 54-74.〕

朱丽叶·科宾, 安塞尔姆·施特劳斯, 2015. 质性研究的基础: 形成扎根理论的程序与方法[M]. 重庆：重庆大学出版社.〔CORBYN J, STRAUSS A, 2015. Basics of qualitative research: Techniques and procedures for developing grounded theory[M]. Chongqing：Chongqing University Press.〕

BURRITT R L, CHRIST K L, OMORI A, 2016. Drivers of corporate water-related disclosure: evidence from Japan[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 129(15): 65-74.

CALVO-MENDIETA I, PETIT O, VIVIEN F D, 2017. Common patrimony: a concept to analyze collective natural resource management: the case of water management in France[J]. Ecological Economics, 137: 126-132.

GLASER B G, STRAUSS A L, STRUTZEL E, 1968. The discovery of grounded theory: strategies for qualitative research[J]. Nursing Research,17(4): 364-377.

JOA B, HOTTENROTH H, JUNGMICHEL N, et al, 2014. Introduction of a feasible performance indicator for corporate water accounting: a case study on the cotton textile chain[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 82: 143-153.

KRAUT M, DENNIS P, CONNOLE H, 2012. The efficacy of voluntary disclosure: a study of water disclosures by mining companies using the global reporting initiative framework[J]. Academy of Accounting & Financial Studies, 17(2): 23-35.

LIU C Y, SU K, ZHANG M M, 2021. Water disclosure and financial reporting quality for social changes: empirical evidence from China[J]. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 166(2): 120571.

REMALI A R M, ALI I M, ALRAZI B, et al, 2017. The development and application of water governance matrix: a case of Malaysia[EB/OL]. (2017-04-01)[2022-05-23]. https://www.shsconferences.org/articles/shsconf/pdf/2017/04/shsconf_icga2017_00013.pdf.

RIDOUTT B G, EADY S J, SELLAHEWA J, et al, 2009. Water footprinting at the product brand level: case study and future challenges[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 17(13): 1228-1235.

WEBER O, SAUNDERS-HOGBERG G, 2018. Water management and corporate social performance in the food and beverage industry[J]. Journal of Cleaner Production, 195: 963-977.

YU H C, 2021. Creating environmental sustainability: determining factors of water resources information disclosure among Chinese enterprises[J/OL]. (2021-08-10)[2022-06-02]. Sustainability Accounting, Management and Policy Journal (ahead-of-print), https://www.researchgate.net/publication/353932830_Creating_environmental_sustainability_determining_factors_of_water_resources_information_disclosure_among_Chinese_enterprises.

[1]	张倩, 沈菊琴, 孙付华, 等. 企业水信息披露影响因素实证研究——基于中国化工行业上市企业的数据[J]. 资源与产业, 2021, 23(4): 53-62.
[2]	赵勇. 矿业企业矿业权资产证券化研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2016, 18(1): 118-125.
[3]	杨永伟，王训练. 中国海外矿业企业人身和财产安全问题与对策研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2015, 17(5): 35-40.
[4]	边一，王浦.. 我国矿业企业对外投资中的社会责任问题研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2013, 15(2): 60-63.
[5]	黄兆锋. 金融危机下中国矿业如何提高竞争力[J]. 资源与产业, 2009, 11(6): 16-20.
[6]	王志强肖荣阁. 国际化视野中的我国矿业企业全面风险管理[J]. 资源与产业, 2009, 11(3): 66-69.
[7]	张雪梅肖荣阁周乐. 矿业企业环境治理投资决策方法研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2009, 11(3): 91-94.