新能源汽车产业集聚对区域绿色经济效率的影响——基于长江经济带的实证研究

doi:10.13776/j.cnki.resourcesindustries.20231213.002

资源与产业 ›› 2024, Vol. 26 ›› Issue (1): 35-49.DOI: 10.13776/j.cnki.resourcesindustries.20231213.002

新能源汽车产业集聚对区域绿色经济效率的影响——基于长江经济带的实证研究

杨恺钧^1,2,3,4,5,6,曹安琪^1,2,3,4,5,6,方慈慧¹

（1.河海大学商学院，江苏南京 211100；2.河海大学东方管理与水管理文化研究中心，江苏南京 211100；3.江苏省“世界水谷与水生态文明建设”协同创新中心，江苏南京 211100；4.江苏省企业国际化发展研究基地，江苏南京 211100；5.河海大学长江保护与绿色发展研究院，江苏南京 211100；6.江苏长江保护与高质量发展研究基地，江苏南京 211100）

收稿日期:2023-04-11 修回日期:2023-05-17 出版日期:2024-02-20 发布日期:2024-02-20
通讯作者: 曹安琪，硕士生，主要从事应用经济学研究。E-mail:1084602091@qq.com
作者简介:杨恺钧，博士、副教授，主要从事环境经济学和区域经济学研究。E-mail:niceyoung@126.com
基金资助:
河海大学中央高校基本科研业务费专项（B230207005）;教育部主题案例（ZT-221029401)。

IMPACTS OF NEW ENERGY VEHICLE INDUSTRIAL AGGLOMERATION ON REGIONAL GREEN ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY BASED ON A CASE STUDY ON YANGTZE RIVER ECONOMIC ZONE

YANG Kaijun^1,2,3,4,5,6, CAO Anqi^1,2,3,4,5,6, FANG Cihui¹

(1.Business School, Hohai University, Nanjing 211100, China; 2.Research Center for Oriental Management and Water Management Culture, Hohai University, Nanjing 211100, China; 3.Jiangsu Collaborative Innovation Center for World Water Valley and Water Ecological Civilization, Nanjing 211100, China; 4.Internationalization Development Research Base of Jiangsu’s Firms, Nanjing 211100, China; 5.Institute of Yangtze River Protection and Green Development, Hohai University, Nanjing 211100, China; 6.Jiangsu Research Base of Yangtze River Protection and Quality Development, Nanjing 211100, China)

Received:2023-04-11 Revised:2023-05-17 Online:2024-02-20 Published:2024-02-20

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 将产业集聚、绿色技术创新和绿色经济效率纳入同一研究框架，聚焦长江经济带，研究新能源汽车产业集聚对绿色经济效率的影响，为我国在“双碳”背景下推进实现制造强国的战略目标及长江经济带新能源汽车发展提供参考。论文基于2012—2020年长江经济带沿线11个省市面板数据，综合利用超效率SBM和区位熵法，构建计量模型，实证研究新能源汽车产业集聚对绿色经济效率的影响，探讨绿色技术创新的中介效应，并进一步分析新能源汽车产业集聚对绿色经济效率的空间溢出效应和区域异质性。研究结果表明：1）长江经济带整个区域已形成“带状”新能源汽车产业集聚区，集聚平均水平随年份波动上升，上中下游产业集聚水平呈递增格局，水平差异较大且有逐渐增加趋势；2）新能源汽车产业集聚通过整合内部网络资源和提升外部整体能力，对长江经济带绿色经济效率具有正向促进作用；3）产业集聚的发展通过竞争效应和合作效应促进绿色技术创新，而绿色技术创新的发展可以提升经济动力和效率，因而绿色技术创新在产业集聚与绿色经济效率之间具有中介作用；4）新能源汽车产业集聚对绿色经济效率具有空间溢出效应，上中下游新能源汽车产业集聚对绿色经济效率的影响存在差异。据此，从加强产业集群建设，发挥新能源汽车产业发展的长效机制、强化发展绿色技术创新体系和推动新能源汽车区域异质性发展三个方面提出对策建议。

关键词: 新能源汽车, 产业集聚, 绿色经济效率, 绿色技术创新, 长江经济带

Abstract:

This paper incorporates industrial agglomeration, green technical innovation and green economic efficiency to study the impact of new energy vehicle industrial agglomeration on green economic efficiency in Yangtze River economic zone, aiming at offering references for China to reach strategic objectives of manufacturing power and to develop new energy vehicles in Yangtze River economic zone under the dual-carbon settings. This paper, based on 11 provinces/cities’ 2012 to 2020 panel data along Yangtze River economic zone, uses super-efficiency SBM and locality entropy to establish a measuring model, which is employed to study impacts of new energy vehicle industrial agglomeration on green economic efficiency. And discusses mediating effects of green technical innovation. The spatial overflowing effects and regional heterogeneity of new-energy vehicle industrial agglomeration on green economic efficiency also were analyzed. The entire Yangtze River economic zone has become a zoned new energy vehicle industrial agglomeration area, with its agglomerating level fluctuating up over years, and increasing from down- to upper-stream with growing variance. New energy vehicle industrial agglomeration promotes the green economic efficiency in Yangtze River economic zone through consolidating internal network resources and boosting external entire capabilities. Development of industrial agglomeration promotes green technical innovation through competition and cooperation, and development of green technical innovation can also boost economic drives and efficiency, proving its mediation between industrial agglomeration and green economic efficiency. New energy vehicle industrial agglomeration has spatial overflowing on green economic efficiency, varying among upper-, middle- and down-stream. This paper presents suggestions on enhancing industrial clustering construction to play a role in the long-term mechanism of new energy vehicle industry, boosting green technical innovation system and advancing regional heterogeneity of new energy vehicle.

Key words: new energy vehicles, industrial agglomeration, green economic efficiency, green technical innovation, Yangtze River economic zone

中图分类号:

F205
F062.9

杨恺钧, 曹安琪, 方慈慧. 新能源汽车产业集聚对区域绿色经济效率的影响——基于长江经济带的实证研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2024, 26(1): 35-49.

YANG Kaijun, CAO Anqi, FANG Cihui. IMPACTS OF NEW ENERGY VEHICLE INDUSTRIAL AGGLOMERATION ON REGIONAL GREEN ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY BASED ON A CASE STUDY ON YANGTZE RIVER ECONOMIC ZONE[J]. Resources & Industries, 2024, 26(1): 35-49.

参考文献

蔡德发, 董秋菊, 朱悦, 等, 2022. 产业集聚、人口结构与绿色经济效率[J]. 统计与决策, 38(7): 112-116.

曹休宁, 戴振, 2009. 产业集聚环境中的企业合作创新行为分析[J]. 经济地理, 29(8): 1323-1326, 1271. 〔CAO X N, DAI Z, 2009. An analysis of firm’s cooperation innovation in agglomeration clusters[J]. Economic Geography, 29(8): 1323-1326, 1271.〕

陈建军, 2004. 长江三角洲地区的产业同构及产业定位[J]. 中国工业经济(2): 19-26. 〔CHEN J J, 2004. Study on same structure and position of industry in delta area of Changjiang river[J]. China Industrial Economics(2): 19-26.〕

陈建军, 胡晨光, 2008. 产业集聚的集聚效应：以长江三角洲次区域为例的理论和实证分析[J]. 管理世界(6): 68-83.

崔新蕾, 李蒙, 王丹丹, 2021. 财政压力、产业结构调整与绿色经济效率[J]. 资源与产业, 23(5): 98-108.〔CUI X L, LI M, WANG D D, 2021. Financial pressure, industrial structure adjustment and green economic efficiency[J]. Resources & Industries, 23(5): 98-108.〕

段辉, 2015. 拥挤的循环与城市规模的演变：基于人均资本波动的分析[J]. 城市问题(10): 19-23. 〔DUAN H, 2015. Congestion circulation and the evolution of city size: based on the per capital fluctuation[J]. Urban Problems(10): 19-23.〕

方杏村, 田淑英, 王晓玲, 2019. 财政分权、产业集聚与绿色经济效率：基于270个地级及以上城市面板数据的实证分析[J]. 经济问题探索(11): 164-172. 〔FANG X C, TIAN S Y, WANG X L, 2019. Fiscal decentralization industrial agglomeration and green efficiency：empirical analysis based on panel data of 270 cities at preference level or above[J]. Inquiry into Economic Issues(11): 164-172.〕

冯锐, 2022. 金融集聚、绿色技术创新和绿色经济效率[J].经济经纬, 39(4): 150-160. 〔FENG R, 2022. Financial agglomeration, green technology innovation and green economic efficiency[J]. Economic Survey, 39(4): 150-160.〕

胡安军, 郭爱君, 钟方雷, 等, 2018. 高新技术产业集聚能够提高地区绿色经济效率吗?[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 28(9): 93-101. 〔HU A J, GUO A J, ZHONG F L, et al., 2018. Can the high-tech industrial agglomeration improve the green economic efficiency of the region?[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 28(9): 93-101.〕

黄永春, 宫尚俊, 邹晨, 等, 2022. 数字经济、要素配置效率与城乡融合发展[J].中国人口·资源与环境, 32(10): 77-87. 〔HUANG Y C, GONG S J, ZOU C, et al., 2022. Digital economy, factor allocation efficiency, and integrated urban-rural development[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 32(10): 77-87.〕

黎文靖, 郑曼妮, 2016. 实质性创新还是策略性创新?：宏观产业政策对微观企业创新的影响[J]. 经济研究, 51(4): 60-73. 〔LI W J, ZHEN M N, 2016. Is it substantive innovation or strategic innovation?：Impact of macroeconomic policies on micro-enterprises’ innovation[J]. Economic Research Journal, 51(4): 60-73.〕

李金培, 徐丽群, 唐方成, 等, 2021. 公共交通设施规模对绿色经济效率的影响[J]. 系统管理学报, 30(6): 1053-1066. 〔LI J P, XU L Q, ZHOU F C, et al., 2021. The impact of public transport facility scale on green economy efficiency[J]. Journal of Systems & Management, 30(6): 1053-1066.〕

李扬, 李华姣, 冯思达, 2023.中国新能源汽车产业供需依赖网络演化机制研究[J].资源与产业, 25(3):69-81. 〔LI Y, LI H J, FENG S D, 2023. Evolutionary mechanism of supply-demand dependence network in China’s new energy vehicle industry[J]. Resources & Industries, 25(3):69-81.〕

林伯强, 谭睿鹏, 2019. 中国经济集聚与绿色经济效率[J]. 经济研究, 54(2): 119-132. 〔LIN B Q, TAN R P, 2019. Economic agglomeration and green economy efficiency in China[J]. Economic Research Journal, 54(2): 119-132.〕

林毅夫, 刘培林, 2003. 中国的经济发展战略与地区收入差距[J]. 经济研究(3): 19-25, 89. 〔LIN Y F, LIU P L, 2003. Chinese development strategy and economic convergence[J]. Economic Research Journal(3): 19-25, 89.〕

刘强, 马彦瑞, 徐生霞, 2022. 数字经济发展是否提高了中国绿色经济效率？[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 32(3): 72-85. 〔LIU Q, MA Y R, XU S X, 2022. Has the development of digital economy improved the efficiency of China’s green economy?[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 32(3): 72-85.〕

刘新智, 张鹏飞, 史晓宇, 2022. 产业集聚、技术创新与经济高质量发展：基于我国五大城市群的实证研究[J]. 改革(4): 68-87. 〔LIU X Z, ZHANG P F, SHI X Y, 2022. Industrial agglomeration,technological innovation and high-quality economic development: empirical research based on China’s five major urban agglomerations[J]. Reform(4): 68-87.〕

刘雅琴, 余谦, 2020. 新能源汽车产业技术创新网络的时空演化与创新集聚[J]. 大连理工大学学报(社会科学版), 41(6): 36-44. 〔LIU Y Q, Y Q, 2020. Temporal-spatial evolution and innovation agglomeration of technological innovation network in new energy vehicle industry[J]. Journal of Dalian University of Technology(Social Sciences), 41(6): 36-44.〕

刘耀彬, 袁华锡, 王喆, 2017. 文化产业集聚对绿色经济效率的影响：基于动态面板模型的实证分析[J]. 资源科学, 39(4): 747-755. 〔LIU Y B, YUAN H X, WANG Z, 2017. Dynamic panel data modeling of the effects of cultural industry clusters on green economic efficiency[J]. Resources Science, 39(4): 747-755.〕

齐绍洲, 林屾, 王班班, 2015. 中部六省经济增长方式对区域碳排放的影响：基于Tapio脱钩模型、面板数据的滞后期工具变量法的研究[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 25(5): 59-66. 〔QI S Z, LIN C, WANG B B, 2015. Impact of economic growth pattern of the six provinces of central China on regional carbon emission: based on the Tapio model and lag instrumental variable analysis of panel data[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 25(5): 59-66.〕

钱争鸣, 刘晓晨, 2014. 我国绿色经济效率的区域差异及收敛性研究[J]. 厦门大学学报(哲学社会科学版)(1): 110-118. 〔QIAN Z M, LIU X C, 2014. A study of regional differences and convergence of green economic efficiency in China[J]. Journal of Xiamen University(A Bimonthly for Studies in Arts & Social Sciences)(1): 110-118.〕

任晓松, 刘宇佳, 赵国浩, 2020. 经济集聚对碳排放强度的影响及传导机制[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 30(4): 95-106. 〔REN X S, LIU Y J, ZHAO G H, 2020. The impact and transmission mechanism of economic agglomeration on carbon intensity[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 30(4): 95-106.〕

沈玉芳, 刘曙华, 张婧, 等, 2010. 长三角地区产业群、城市群和港口群协同发展研究[J]. 经济地理, 30(5): 778-783.〔SHEN Y F, LIU S H, ZHANG J, et al., 2010. The correspondence among industrial cluster, city group and port group on the Yangtze Delta area[J]. Economic Geography, 30(5): 778-783.〕

孙瑜康, 李国平, 袁薇薇, 等, 2017. 创新活动空间集聚及其影响机制研究评述与展望[J].人文地理, 32(5): 17-24. 〔SUN Y K, LI G P, YUAN W W, et al., 2017. The spatial concentration of innovation and its mechanisms: A literature review and prospect[J]. Human Geography, 32(5): 17-24.〕

孙正, 杨素, 刘瑾瑜, 2021. 我国生产性服务业与制造业协同融合程度测算及其决定因素研究[J]. 中国软科学(7): 31-39. 〔SUN Z, YANG S, LIU J Y, 2021. Calculation of the degree of synergy and integration between producer service industry and manufacturing industry and its determinants[J]. China Soft Science(7): 31-39.〕

田建国, 王玉海, 2018. 财政分权、地方政府竞争和碳排放空间溢出效应分析[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 28(10): 36-44. 〔TIAN J G, WANG Y H, 2018. Spatial spillover effects between fiscal decentralization ,local governments competition and carbon emissions[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 28(10): 36-44.〕

王志祥, 张洪振, 龚新蜀, 等, 2018. 物流产业集聚、市场分割与区域绿色经济效率[J]. 经济经纬, 35(5): 87-93. 〔WANG Z X, ZHANG H Z, GONG X S, et al., 2018. Logistics industry agglomeration ,market segmentation and regional green economic efficiency[J]. Economic Survey, 35(5): 87-93.〕

吴传清, 周西一敏, 2020. 长江经济带绿色经济效率的时空格局演变及其影响因素研究[J]. 宏观质量研究, 8(3): 120-128. 〔WU C Q, ZHOU X Y M, 2020. Research on the spatiotemporal evolution and the influencing factors of green economic efficiency in the Yangtze River Economic belt[J]. Journal of Macro-quality Research, 8(3): 120-128.〕

辛龙, 孙慧, 王慧, 等, 2020. 基于地理探测器的绿色经济效率时空分异及驱动力研究[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 30(9): 128-138. 〔XIN L, SUN H, WANG H, et al., 2020. Research on the spatial-temporal differentiation and driving force of green economic efficiency based on the geographic detector model[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 30(9): 128-138.〕

许和连, 邓玉萍, 2012. 外商直接投资导致了中国的环境污染吗?：基于中国省际面板数据的空间计量研究[J]. 管理世界(2): 30-43.

杨仁发, 2015. 产业集聚能否改善中国环境污染[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境, 25(2): 23-29. 〔YANG R F, 2015. Whether industrial agglomeration can reduce environmental pollution or not[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 25(2): 23-29.〕

叶振宇, 庄宗武, 2022. 产业链龙头企业与本地制造业企业成长：动力还是阻力[J]. 中国工业经济(7): 141-158. 〔YE Z Y, ZHUANG Z W, 2022. Industrial chain leading firms and local manufacturing firm’s growth: driving force or resistance[J]. China Industrial Economics(7): 141-158.〕

尹庆民, 靳婉婷, 2023. 科技创新对绿色全要素生产率的影响：基于产业集聚调节作用[J].资源与产业, 25(2): 1-10. 〔YIN Q M, JIN W T, 2023. Impacts of technical innovation on green total factor productivity based on adjustment of industrial agglomeration[J]. Resources & Industries, 25(2): 1-10.〕

余东华, 吕逸楠, 2015. 政府不当干预与战略性新兴产业产能过剩：以中国光伏产业为例[J]. 中国工业经济(10): 53-68. 〔YU D H, LV Y N, 2015. Government improper intervention and overcapacity of strategic emerging industries：a case study of Chinese photovoltaic industry[J]. China Industrial Economics(10): 53-68.〕

张娜, 郭爱君, 2022. 服务业集聚对黄河流域城市绿色经济效率的影响研究[J]. 城市问题(4): 35-44, 86.〔ZHANG N, GUO A J, 2022. The impact of service industry agglomeration on green economic efficiency of cities in the Yellow River Basin[J]. Urban Problems(4): 35-44, 86.〕

张平淡, 屠西伟, 2021. 制造业集聚促进中国绿色经济效率提升了吗?[J]. 北京师范大学学报(社会科学版)(1): 132-144. 〔ZHANG P D, TU X W, 2021. Has manufacturing agglomeration promoted promoted the efficiency of China’s green economy?[J]. Journal of Beijing Normal University(Social Sciences)(1): 132-144.〕

周杰文, 蒋正云, 李凤, 2019. 我国旅游产业集聚对绿色经济效率的影响：基于省级面板数据的实证研究[J].生态经济, 35(3): 122-128. 〔ZHOU J W, JIANG Z Y, LI F, 2019. The impact of tourism industry agglomeration on the efficiency of green economy: an empirical research based on provincial panel data[J]. Ecological Economy, 35(3): 122-128.〕

周亚虹, 蒲余路, 陈诗一, 等, 2015. 政府扶持与新型产业发展：以新能源为例[J]. 经济研究, 50(6): 147-161. 〔ZHOU Y H, PU Y L, CHEN S Y, et al., 2015. Government support and development of emerging industries：a new energy industry survey[J]. Economic Research Journal, 50(6): 147-161.〕

周燕, 潘遥, 2019. 财政补贴与税收减免：交易费用视角下的新能源汽车产业政策分析[J]. 管理世界, 35(10): 133-149. 〔ZHOU Y, PAN Y, 2019. Subsidization versus tax reduction: the policy choice for new energy vehicles under the constraints of transaction costs[J]. Journal of Management World, 35(10): 133-149.〕

朱英明, 2003. 产业集聚研究述评[J]. 经济评论(3): 117-121.

BARBERA A J, MCCONNELL V D, 1990. The impact of environmental regulations on industry productivity：direct and indirect effects[J]. Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 18(1): 50-65.

BENHABIB J, SPIEGEL M M, 1994. The role of human capital in economic development evidence from aggregate cross-country data[J]. Journal of monetary economics, 34(2): 143-173.

CHENG Z H, LI L S, LIU J, 2018. Industrial structure, technical progress and carbon intensity in China’s provinces[J]. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 81(2): 2935-2946.

FUJITA M, THISSE J F, 1996. Economics of agglomeration[J]. Journal of the Japanese and International Economies, 10(4): 339-378.

GROSSMAN G M, KRUEGER A B, 1995. Economic growth and the environment[J]. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 110(2): 353-377.

LAN J, KAKINAKA M, HUANG X G, 2012. Foreign direct investment, human capital and environmental pollution in China[J]. Environmental and Resource Economics, 51(2): 255-275.

LI H, FANG K N, YANG W, et al., 2013. Regional environmental efficiency evaluation in China: Analysis based on the Super-SBM model with undesirable outputs[J]. Mathematical & Computer Modelling, 58(5-6): 1018-1031.

SHUAI S, FAN Z, 2020. Modeling the role of environmental regulations in regional green economy efficiency of China: empirical evidence from super efficiency DEA-Tobit model[J]. Journal of Environmental Management, 261(1): 110227.

TONE K, 2001. A slacks-based measure of efficiency in data envelopment analysis[J]. European Journal of Operational Research, 130(3): 498-509.

WILLIAMSON J G, 1965. Regional inequality and the process of national development： a description of the patterns[J]. Economic development and cultural change, 13(4): 1-84.

[1]	李扬, 李华姣, 冯思达. 中国新能源汽车产业供需依赖网络演化机制研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(3): 69-81.
[2]	仇蕾, 马蓓文, 周钦, 程常高. 环境规制对重污染企业投资偏好的影响——基于我国A股上市公司的经验证据[J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(3): 92-106.
[3]	尹庆民, 靳婉婷. 科技创新对绿色全要素生产率的影响——基于产业集聚调节作用[J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(2): 1-10.
[4]	杨恺钧, 段婷婷. 水资源约束对长江经济带绿色发展效率的影响——基于产业结构调整的中介效应和交互效应 [J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(2): 11-22.
[5]	黄子琦, 刘清泉. 长江经济带产业协同集聚对绿色技术创新的影响机制——基于税收竞争的中介效应 [J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(2): 23-36.
[6]	及添正, 黄巧龙, 张天铃, 等. 长江经济带生产性服务业的空间格局演变与影响因素研究——基于企业进入视角 [J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(2): 37-51.
[7]	马骏, 高慧娴, 石艳秋. 长江经济带碳补偿量化与时空格局研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(2): 52-64.
[8]	高枝欣, 许纪校. 重污染企业社会责任、高管激励与绿色技术创新[J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(2): 88-100.
[9]	王伟. 产业集聚、城市集聚与绿色全要素生产率——以长江经济带城市群为例[J]. 资源与产业, 2022, 24(6): 75-89.
[10]	华坚, 刘蕾, 施明月. 长江经济带水利建设投资对水资源绿色效率的影响 [J]. 资源与产业, 2022, 24(6): 103-115.
[11]	陈书伟, 韩丽. 政府创新补贴促进了企业绿色技术创新水平吗？——基于信号传递的视角[J]. 资源与产业, 2022, 24(5): 98-107.
[12]	张云宁, 朱红艳, 欧阳红祥, 等. 长江经济带乡村人居环境可持续发展水平评价与空间格局研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2022, 24(4): 42-54.
[13]	王保乾, 李昕燃. 基于水足迹与SBM-Malmquist模型的长江经济带工业水资源绿色效率的研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2022, 24(3): 21-31.
[14]	马骏, 伍琳玲, 卢玉钦. 碳排放视域下长江经济带绿色发展效率测度及影响因素研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2022, 24(3): 71-80.
[15]	王保乾, 范哲艳. 高技术产业集聚对绿色水资源效率的影响研究——基于空间杜宾模型[J]. 资源与产业, 2022, 24(2): 86-96.

新能源汽车产业集聚对区域绿色经济效率的影响——基于长江经济带的实证研究

IMPACTS OF NEW ENERGY VEHICLE INDUSTRIAL AGGLOMERATION ON REGIONAL GREEN ECONOMIC EFFICIENCY BASED ON A CASE STUDY ON YANGTZE RIVER ECONOMIC ZONE

PDF

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

参考文献

相关文章 15

编辑推荐

Metrics