CHINA’S
2012 TO 2021 INDUSTRIAL DEVIATION BASED ON IMPROVED THEIL INDEX AND SHIFT-SHARE
MODEL

doi:10.13776/j.cnki.resourcesindustries.20231212.002

Abstract

Abstract:

Overviews over references reveal that defects are existing in traditional industrial deviation E coefficient, Theil Index and Shift-Share model. Defects in E coefficient and Theil Index are in calculating principles, and those in Shift-Share model are in rationality of selecting reference system and feasibility of data collection. This paper presents an improved model that is used to study China’s 2012 to 2021 industrial deviation via cases. It concludes that China’s industrial deviation is diminishing. According to the corrected model and combined with the current global environment, this paper suggests that the first industry rely on scientific innovation to promote rural labors’ orderly migration between urban and rural areas and to materialize agricultural scale and modernization, that the second industry needs to be upgraded to reach and maintain an independent and complete industrial system, to inputs more in basic research to outbreak western technical blockage, that the third industry be focusing on financing and scientific education, increasing Hongkong, Shanghai and Beijing’s positions in world financing center, using financial innovation to avoid unfavorable constraints and impacts from global financing system, practicing the strategy for invigorating the country through science and education and exploring educational modes appropriate China’s situation from primary school to university stages.

Key words: three industries, deviation degree, Theil Index, Shift-Share model, industrial structural optimization

摘要：

文章首先通过对现有文献的梳理和分析，发现针对产业偏离的测算，传统的产业偏离度E系数、Theil指数及Shift-Share模型均存在一定的缺陷， E系数和Theil指数的缺陷主要体现在计算原理方面，而Shift-Share模型的缺陷主要表现在参照系选择的合理性和数据采集的可行性方面。然后，基于现有模型的基本原理，提出了更为合理和更具可操作性的产业偏离测算方法，再采用实证研究的方法，根据2012—2021年的数据，对中国的产业偏离情况进行具体分析，得出尽管中国存在产业偏离，但产业偏离度在逐渐减小。最后，基于修正模型的计算结果，并结合当前的国际国内环境，提出如下政策建议：1）第一产业要依靠创新和科技引领，促进农村劳动力在城乡间有序转移，实现农业生产的规模化和现代化；2）第二产业要加快产业的升级换代，建立和保持独立、自主、完整的工业体系，加大在基础研究方面的投入，尽早突破美西方的技术封锁；3）第三产业的发展重点应该在金融和科教两个方面，要进一步提升香港、上海和北京等城市的世界金融中心地位，依靠金融创新来规避现行国际金融体系的不利约束和影响，同时要将科教兴国战略落到实处，努力探索适合中国国情的从小学到大学各阶段的教育模式。

关键词: 三次产业, 偏离度, Theil系数, Shift-Share模型, 产业结构优化

CLC Number:

F205
F062.9

GAO Xiaowei, ZHANG Yingkun, LI Hua, et al.. CHINA’S 2012 TO 2021 INDUSTRIAL DEVIATION BASED ON IMPROVED THEIL INDEX AND SHIFT-SHARE MODEL[J]. Resources & Industries, 2024, 26(1): 15-24.

高孝伟, 张颖昆, 李华, 等. 基于改进Theil指数和Shift-Share模型的2012-2021年中国产业偏离分析[J]. 资源与产业, 2024, 26(1): 15-24.

References

曹玉昆, 黄显乔, 朱震锋, 2018. 基于偏离-份额法的国有林区产业结构分析[J]. 林业经济问题, 38(2): 1-7.〔CAO Y K, HUANG X Q, ZHU Z F, 2018. Analysis of industrial structure in SFR based on the shift share method[J]. Issues of Forestry Economics, 38(2): 1-7.〕

段禄峰, 2016. 我国产业结构偏离度研究[J]. 统计与决策(6): 122-125.

干春晖, 2011. 中国产业结构变迁对经济增长和波动的影响[J]. 国民经济管理(人大复印)(8): 11-24.

高利梅, 2022. 基于偏离份额法的青岛市海洋产业结构分析[J]. 科技创业月刊, 35(11): 38-41.〔Gao L M, 2022. Analysis of marine industry structure in Qingdao based on SSM[J]. Pioneering with Science & Technology Monthly, 35(11): 38-41.〕

关成华, 2023. 中国城市化进程新特征[J]. 人民论坛(2): 62-65.

黄鹏, 2016. 张家港建市后产业偏离度演进历史[J]. 现代商贸工业(30): 20-21.

江涌, 2015. 道路之争：工业化还是金融化[M]. 北京: 中国人民大学出版社: 244.

金碚, 2015. 中国制造2025[M]. 北京: 中信出版社: 263-264.

雷钧钧, 2021. 基于偏离-份额分析法的长沙市产业结构演变研究[J]. 经济与社会发展研究(16): 15-18.

李兵红. 2021. 基于“偏离- 份额分析法”的兰州市榆中县产业发展评价及主导产业选择研究[J]. 品牌研究(17): 124-127.

李添喜, 张玉, 2022. 基于偏离-份额分析的产业竞争力研究：以江西省永修县为例[J]. 老区建设(11): 48-53.

卢幸芷, 陈珈琪, 2021, 杜也. 基于偏离-份额分析的浙江省产业结构演进研究[J]. 中国集体经济(27): 64-67.

吕洁华, 刘艳迪, 付思琦, 等, 2018. 黑龙江省林下经济优势产业的选择分析：基于偏离-份额分析法[J]. 林业经济问题, 18(4): 72-77.〔LYU J H, LIU Y D, FU S Q, et al., 2018. Analysis on the selection of competitive industries of economy relying on forest in Heilongjiang province: based on the shift-share analysis[J]. Issues of Forestry Economics, 18(4): 72-77.〕

马庆, 2020. 行业视角下的第三产业发展与就业协调性研究：基于改进的结构偏离度分析[J]. 技术经济与管理(10): 94-98.〔MA Q, 2020. The Research on the coordination of tertiary industry development and employment: based on the improved structural deviation degree[J]. Journal of Technical Economics & Management(10): 94-98.〕

孙少华, 2019. 基于偏离份额分析的长春市产业结构研究[J] . 商场现代化(19): 151-153.

田静, 2011. 产业偏离度、劳动力转移与社会就业的实证分析[J]. 统计与决策(21): 95-97.

王朗, 沙景华, 2013. 西北五省矿业产业偏离份额分析[J]. 中国矿业, 22(12): 35-40.〔WANG L, SHA J H, 2013 . Shift-share analysis of mining industry in Inner Mongolia, Shaanxi, Gansu, Ningxia and Xinjiang provinces[J]. China Mining Magazine, 22(12): 35-40.〕

王迎涛, 2018. 河南国际旅游产业结构的偏离－份额分析及优化研究[J]. 地域研究与开发, 37(4): 110-113, 137.〔WANG Y T, 2018. Shift-share analysis of Henan tourism industry structure and its optimization[J]. Areal Research and Development, 37(4): 110-113, 137.〕

吴思斌, 刘细发, 2015. 产业偏离优势的测度及对经济增长贡献研究：以山西为例[J]. 贵州财经大学学报(2): 84-91.〔WU S B, LIU X F, 2015. Contribution to economic growth and industry research measure-deviate advantage in Shanxi Province[J]. Journal of Guizhou University of Finance and Economics(2): 84-91.〕

吴旭, 2021. 基于偏离份额分析的合肥市产业结构研究[J]. 对外经贸(5): 59-62.〔WU X, 2021. Research on industrial structure of Hefei based on shift share analysis[J]. Foreign Economic Relations & Trade(5): 59-62.〕

杨晓丹, 茆健, 凌松宇, 2022. 长三角一体化背景下上海市主导产业选择：基于偏离-份额与区位熵的方法[J]. 特区经济, 42(7): 46-49.〔YANG X D, MAO J, LING S Y, 2022. The selection of Shanghai’s leading industries under the background of integration in Yangtze River Delta: based on the shift-share analysis and location entropy[J], Special Zone Economy, 42(7): 46-49.〕

郑蕊, 何珊, 2017. 我国产业结构合理化对经济增长的影响：基于结构偏离度改进视角[J]. 商业经济研究(18): 164-166.

MOGIL A Z, CIOLEK D, KWIATKOWSKI J M, et al., 2021. The baltic blue growth: a country-level shift-share analysis[J]. Marine Policy, 134: 104799.

MONTANIA C V, MRQUEZ M A, TERESA F N, et al., 2021. Spatial shift-share analysis: some new developments[J]. Papers in Regional Science. 100(2): 305-325.

MONTANIA C V, SANDY D, 2022. Multi-dynamic interregional input-output shift-share: model, theory and application[J]. Economic Systems Research, 34(2): 234-251.

NURYASMAN M N, KARTIKA N, COKKI, 2020. Shift-share analysis of tourism industry growth in Kulon Progo Yogyakarta[J]. Industrial Engineering & Management Systems, 19(3): 610-621.

[1]	Hu Yuan, Liu Junfeng, Hu Wei, et al.. REGIONAL VARIANCE, TREND EVOLUTION AND FACTORS OF CHINA’S CARBON EMISSION INTENSITY BASED ON 30 PROVINCES(CITIES AND DISTRICTS)’1997—2012 PANEL DATA [J]. Resources & Industries, 2016, 18(5): 7-13.
[2]	Hu Yuan, Liu Gui-chun, Kong Xiang-zhen, et al. TEMPORALSPATIAL VARIANCE OF CHINA'S CARBON DIOXIDE EMISSION INTENSITY [J]. Resources & Industries, 2016, 18(2): 67-75.
[3]	YANG Yu-dan. URBANIZATION RESPONSE SPATIAL VARIANCE TO INDUSTRIAL STRUCTURE EVOLUTION IN ANHUI PROVINCE [J]. Resources & Industries, 2015, 17(6): 106-115.
[4]	Zhou Mengyan, Ma Hongyun. MARKET POWER OF ELECTRIC POWER INDUSTRY AS THE BUYER OF COAL INDUSTRY [J]. Resources & Industries, 2013, 15(4): 137-142.
[5]	LIU Xiu-xia WANG Guo-liang HOU Feng-bo. STUDY ON URBANIZATION LEVEL DIFFERENCE AMONG CITIES IN SHANDONG [J]. Resources & Industries, 2008, 10(1): 97-100.

CHINA’S 2012 TO 2021 INDUSTRIAL DEVIATION BASED ON IMPROVED THEIL INDEX AND SHIFT-SHARE MODEL

基于改进Theil指数和Shift-Share模型的2012-2021年中国产业偏离分析

PDF

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

References

Related Articles 5

Recommended Articles

Metrics