中国省域农村产业融合水平的空间收敛性与分异特征

doi:10.13776/j.cnki.resourcesindustries.20220915.001

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 农村产业融合既是乡村产业振兴的根本途径，也是减缓“三农”问题的重要手段，提高农村产业融合发展水平是锻铸农村地区经济韧性的关键环节。采用熵权法测算中国31个省份2008—2020年的农村产业融合水平，在考虑空间因素与控制变量的前提条件下，基于空间条件β收敛模型对其收敛性和时空分异特征进行分析。研究发现：1）从农村产业融合水平的测度结果来看，全国层面的总体水平不高，仅完成了目标值的40%；区域层面上，水平增速呈现出“东—西—中”的递减趋势；省域层面上，同一区域内省份间差距小于不同区域的省份间差距。2）从农村产业融合水平的收敛性来看，我国农村产业融合水平具有明显的空间条件β收敛特征，且空间因素的纳入使得收敛周期缩短了约6 a；财政支农、农业技术进步与农村居民消费水平提升促进了农村产业融合水平的提高及高值收敛，而人力资本水平对其收敛具有抑制作用，且表现不明显。3）从农村产业融合水平的时空分异特征来看，空间上，三大区域农村产业融合水平均存在显著的“俱乐部收敛”特征，且收敛率高于全国平均水平，空间正向溢出效应同样强于全国层面；时间上，2016—2020年收敛率高于2008—2015年，经济发展水平、人力资本水平等因素对农村产业融合的作用方向与程度在前后两个时期均有明显差异。为此，提出以下建议：1）充分认识当前现实，继续完善顶层设计，科学引导农业现代化融合方向；2）充分发挥财政支农资金、农业技术进步与农村居民消费水平提升的促进作用，改善农村产业融合水平的非均衡区域分布现状；3）重视“人才红利”优势，充分发挥人力资本对农村产业融合水平提升及高值收敛的正向促进作用；4）树立全国“整盘蛋糕”的农村产业融合系统观念，实现全国农村产业融合均衡发展。

关键词: 农村产业融合, 条件β收敛, 空间收敛, 时空分异, SDM模型, 熵权法

Abstract: Rural industrial integration is a fundamental approach to agricultural industrial bloom, and also a key solution to rural, agricultural and farmers’ issues. Increasing rural industrial integration level is a critical means to agricultural economy. This paper uses entropy weights to estimate 31 Chinese provinces’ 2008 to 2020 rural industrial integration level, and analyzes the spatial convergence and differentiated characteristic based on spatial conditionalβconvergence model. Results show that rural industrial integration level is low, only 40% of the target. Regionally, horizontal rising rate displays a deceasing tend from east, west and to central. Provincewide variance is less than cross-provincial. China’s rural industrial integration level is outstandingly of spatially conditionalβconvergence, with its convergence period shortened by 6 years. Rural industrial integration level is mostly contributed by financing agriculture, agricultural technical advances and farmers’ rising consumption level, but its convergence is slightly constrained by human capital. Spatially, rural industrial integration level in three areas is of notable “club convergence”, higher that the national average, also with a stronger spatial positive overflowing effect. Temporally, convergence rate in 2016 to 2020 is higher than 2008 to 2015, in which economic development and human capital work variably in direction and extent. This paper presents suggestions on optimizing top design, and modernizing agricultural industries, boosting financing agriculture, agricultural technical advances and farmers’ consumption level, improving imbalanced agricultural industrial integration, paying attention on talents, fulfilling the positive promotion of human capital on rural industrial integration level and high value convergence, and establishing a concept of wholly national rural industrial integration system and realizing a balanced development of nationwide rural industrial integration.

Key words: agricultural industrial integration, conditional β convergence, spatial convergence, temporalspatial differentiation, SDM model, entropy weight

中图分类号:

F323.1

赵敏, 储佩佩. 中国省域农村产业融合水平的空间收敛性与分异特征[J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(1): 51-66.

ZHAO Min, CHU Peipei. SPATIAL CONVERGENCE AND DIFFERENTIATED CHARACTERISTICS OF CHINA'S PROVINCIAL RURAL INDUSTRIAL INTEGRATION LEVEL [J]. Resources & Industries, 2023, 25(1): 51-66.

参考文献

陈池波, 李硕, 田云, 2021. 中国农村一二三产业融合度与省际比较分析[J]. 农业工程学报, 37（2）: 326-334.〔CHEN C B, LI S, TIAN Y, 2021. Integration of three industries in rural China and its provincial comparative analysis[J]. Transactions of the Chinese Society of Agricultural Engineering, 37（2）: 326-334.〕

陈红霞, 雷佳, 2021. 农村一二三产业融合水平测度及时空耦合特征分析[J]. 中国软科学（S1）: 357-364.〔CHEN H X, LEI J, 2021. Analysis of the level measurement and the temporal-spatial coupling characteristics of rural industrial convergence[J]. China Soft Science（S1）: 357-364.〕

陈赞章, 2019. 乡村振兴视角下农村产业融合发展政府推进模式研究[J]. 理论探讨（3）: 119-124.

成德宁, 2012. 我国农业产业链整合模式的比较与选择[J]. 经济学家（8）: 52-57.〔CHENG D N, 2012. The comparison and choice of the industrial chain integration model of China's agriculture[J]. Economist（8）: 52-57.〕

程莉, 孔芳霞, 2020. 长江上游地区农村产业融合发展水平测度及影响因素[J]. 统计与信息论坛, 35（1）: 101-111.〔CHENG L, KONG F X, 2020. Study on measurement and influencing factors of rural industrial integration development level in upper reaches of Yangtze River[J]. Statistics & Information Forum, 35（1）: 101-111.〕

程莉, 周芳雅, 王琴, 2021. 农业与服务业融合发展及其农户增收效应研究: 以长江上游地区为例[J]. 西安财经大学学报, 34（3）: 81-91.〔CHENG L, ZHOU F Y, WANG Q, 2021. Research on the integration of agriculture and services and the effect of increasing farmer's income: a case study of the upper reaches of the Yangtze River[J]. Journal of Xian University of Finance and Economics, 34（3）: 81-91.〕

成田拓未, 宋晓凯, 李中华, 2009. 日本农协的发展经验对中国农民专业合作社的启示[J]. 青岛农业大学学报（社会科学版）（1）: 17-21.〔NAVITA T, SONG X K, LI Z H, 2009. Light that development experience of Japanese farmer cooperative shed on Chinese farmer cooperative[J]. Journal of Qingdao Agricultural University（Social Science）（1）: 17-21.〕

崔瑜, 刘文新, 蔡瑜, 等, 2021. 中国农村绿色化发展效率收敛了吗: 基于1997—2017年的实证分析[J]. 农业技术经济（2）: 72-87.〔CUI Y, LIU W X, CAI Y, et al, 2021. Has the efficiency of rural green development converged in China? : an empirical analysis from 1997 to 2017[J]. Journal of Agrotechnical Economics（2）: 72-87.〕

葛继红, 王猛, 汤颖梅, 2022. 农村三产融合、城乡居民消费与收入差距: 效率与公平能否兼得？[J]. 中国农村经济（3）: 50-66.〔GE J H, WANG M, TANG Y M, 2022. Rural industrial integration, consumption of urban and rural residents and urban-rural income gap: can both efficiency and fairness be achieved？[J]. Chinese Rural Economy（3）: 50-66.〕

关浩杰, 2016. 农村产业融合发展综合评价指标体系如何构建[J]. 人民论坛（20）: 52-54.

姜长云, 2016. 推进农村一二三产业融合发展的路径和着力点[J]. 中州学刊（5）: 43-49.〔JIANG C Y, 2016. The paths and key points of promoting industrial integrated development among primary, secondary and tertiary industries in rural China[J]. Academic Journal of Zhongzhou（5）: 43-49.〕

李莉, 景普秋, 2019. 农村网络式产业融合动力机制研究: 基于城乡互动的视角[J]. 农业经济问题（8）: 129-138.〔LI L, JING P Q, 2019. Research on the dynamic mechanism of rural mult-industry integration based on the perspective of urban-rural interaction[J]. Issues in Agricultural Economy（8）: 129-138.〕

李欠男, 李谷成, 高雪, 等, 2019. 农业全要素生产率增长的地区差距及空间收敛性分析[J]. 中国农业资源与区划, 40（7）: 28-36.〔LI Q N, LI G C, GAO X, et al, 2019. Analysis of regional gap and spatital convergence of agricultural total factor productivity growth [J]. Chinese Journal of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning, 40（7）: 28-36.〕

黎新伍, 徐书彬, 2021. 农村产业融合: 水平测度与空间分布格局[J]. 中国农业资源与区划, 42（12）: 60-74.〔LI X W, XU S B, 2021. Rural industrial integration: measurement and spatial distribution pattern[J]. Chinese Journal of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning, 42（12）: 60-74.〕

李宇, 杨敬, 2017. 创新型农业产业价值链整合模式研究: 产业融合视角的案例分析[J]. 中国软科学（3）: 27-36.〔LI Y, YANG J, 2017. Industry chain integration model about agriculture case studies from the perspective of industry convergence[J]. China Soft Science（3）: 27-36.〕

孟秋菊, 2018. 农村产业融合的内涵研究[J]. 四川理工学院学报（社会科学版）, 33（2）: 76-83.〔MENG Q J, 2018. The connotation of rural industrial integration[J]. Journal of Sichuan University of Science & Engineering（Social Sciences Edition）, 33（2）: 76-83.〕

牛文浩, 申淑虹, 张蚌蚌, 2021. 中国乡村振兴5个维度耦合协调空间格局及其影响因素[J]. 中国农业资源与区划, 42（7）: 218-231.〔NIU W H, SHEN S H, ZHANG B B, 2021. Spatial pattern and influencing factors of coordination development of rural revitalization's five dimensions in China[J]. Chinese Journal of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning, 42（7）: 218-231.〕

齐文浩, 李佳俊, 曹建民, 等, 2021. 农村产业融合提高农户收入的机理与路径研究: 基于农村异质性的新视角[J]. 农业技术经济（8）: 105-118.〔QI W H, LI J J, CAO J M, et al, 2021. Research on the mechanism and path of rural industry integration to improve farmers' income: a new perspective based on rural heterogeneity[J]. Journal of Agrotechnical Economics（8）: 105-118.〕

沈冉, 2020. 湖北省农村一二三产业融合及其经济效应的研究[D]. 武汉: 华中农业大学.〔SHEN R, 2020. A study on the integration of primary, secondary and tertiary industries and its economic effects in rural areas of Hubei province[D]. Wuhan: Huazhong Agricultural University.〕

杨珧, 王川, 2021. 基于AHP-模糊综合评价法的农旅融合度分析: 以恩施贡水白柚产业为例[J]. 中国农业资源与区划, 42（1）: 220-230.〔YANG Y, WANG C, 2021. Analysis on the degree of agricultural-tourism integration based on AHP-FUZZY comprehensive evaluation method[J]. Chinese Journal of Agricultural Resources and Regional Planning, 42（1）: 220-230.〕

叶云, 汪发元, 裴潇, 2018. 信息技术产业与农村一二三产业融合: 动力、演进与水平[J]. 农业经济与管理（5）: 20-29.〔YE Y, WANG F Y, PEI X, 2018. Integration of information technology industry and rural industry: drive, evolution and level[J]. Agricultural Economics and Management（5）: 20-29.〕

余涛, 2020. 农村一二三产业融合发展的评价及分析[J]. 宏观经济研究（11）: 76-85.〔YU T, 2020. An evaluation and analysis of the integrated development of rural primary, secondary and tertiary[J]. Macroeconomics（11）: 76-85.〕

张东玲, 范伟丽, 陈景帅, 2021. 农村产业融合、绿色城镇化与城乡均衡发展的协同效应: 基于线性与非线性关系的实证分析[J]. 重庆社会科学（5）: 53-70.〔ZHANG D L, FAN W L, CHEN J S, 2021. The synergistic effect of agricultural industry integration, green urbanization and balanced development between urban and rural areas: empirical analysis based on linear and non-linear relations[J]. Chongqing Social Sciences（5）: 53-70.〕

张林, 温涛, 刘渊博, 2020. 农村产业融合发展与农民收入增长: 理论机理与实证判定[J]. 西南大学学报（社会科学版）, 46（5）: 42-56, 191-192.〔ZHANG L, WEN T, LIU Y B, 2020. Rural industrial convergence development and farmers income increase: theoretical mechanism and empirical determination[J]. Journal of Southwest University（Social Sciences Edition）, 46（5）: 42-56, 191-192.〕

张林, 张雯卿, 2021. 普惠金融与农村产业融合发展的耦合协同关系及动态演进[J]. 财经理论与实践, 42（2）: 2-11.〔ZHANG L, ZHANG W Q, 2021. Study on the coupling cooperative relationship and its dynamic evolution of inclusive finance and integrated development of rural industries[J]. The Theory and Practice of Finance and Economics, 42（2）: 2-11.〕

张文彬, 郝佳馨, 2020. 生态足迹视角下中国能源效率的空间差异性和收敛性研究[J]. 中国地质大学学报（社会科学版）, 20（5）: 76-90.〔ZHANG W B, HAO J X, 2020. Study on regional differences and convergence of energy efficiency in China from the perspective of ecological footprint[J]. Journal of China University of Geosciences（Social Sciences Edition）, 20（5）: 76-90.〕

张艳红, 陈政, 萧烽, 等, 2021. 高质量发展背景下湖南农村产业融合发展水平测度与空间分异研究[J/OL]. 经济地理. （2021-07-20）[2022-09-07]. https: //kns. cnki. net/kcms/detail/43. 1126. k. 20210716. 1312. 002. html.〔ZHANG Y H, CHEN Z, XIAO F, et al, 2021. Research on the measurement and spatial differentiation of Hunan rural industrial integration development level under the background of high-quality development[J]. Economic Geography. （2021-07-20）[2022-09-07]. https: //kns. cnki. net/kcms/detail/43. 1126. k. 20210716. 1312. 002. html.〕

赵俊伟, 尹昌斌, 牛敏杰, 2017. 中国农业生态文明发展水平的时空差异与变动趋势[J]. 财贸研究, 28（6）: 47-57.〔ZHAO J W, YIN C B, NIU M J, 2017. Spatial-temporal difference and trends of agricultural eco-civilization level in China[J]. Finance and Trade Research, 28（6）: 47-57.〕

BOEHLJE M, SCHRADER L F, 1998. The industrialization of agriculture: questions of coordination[M]. Ipswich: The Ipswich Book Company.

FEAGAN R, HENDERSON A, 2009. Devon Acres CSA: local struggles in a global food system[J]. Agriculture & Human Values, 26（3）: 203-217.

JEFFRIES D, 2002. The European Union and European tourism: in search of a policy[J]. Travel & Tourism Analyst（3）: 1-23.

RHODES V J, 1993. Industrialization of agriculture: discussion[J]. American Journal of Agricultural Economics, 75（5）: 1137-1139.

[1]	柯文岚, 李文慧, 闫晶晶. 京津冀城市群高质量发展测度及时空分异特征研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2024, 26(1): 1-14.
[2]	鞠严萍, 王新华. 煤炭行业产能过剩的再认识——基于潜类别随机边界法的测算及其空间演变[J]. 资源与产业, 2023, 25(6): 41-52.
[3]	马瑞. 新发展理念视角下黄河流域9省高质量发展评价与空间分布研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2022, 24(1): 160-171.
[4]	华坚, 庞丽. 科技金融视角下长江经济带经济高质量发展研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2020, 22(4): 12-22.
[5]	孙康，王雁楠，苏子晓. 中国海洋渔业经济效率时空分异研究[J]. 资源与产业, 2020, 22(2): 25-33.
[6]	许加强，于光，何大义. 绿色矿山的多专家综合评价方法探讨——以新汶矿业集团华丰矿山为例 [J]. 资源与产业, 2016, 18(1): 61-68.
[7]	李冉，何大义，许加强. 基于最小叉熵的资源环境承载力多专家综合评价方法[J]. 资源与产业, 2015, 17(4): 69-74.
[8]	赵磊，刘洪彬，于国锋，李铁柱，孙伟，王闯. 基于熵权法土地资源可持续利用综合评价研究——以辽宁省葫芦岛市为例[J]. 资源与产业, 2012, 14(4): 63-69.
[9]	付海波, 孔锐. 基于熵权法的矿产资源竞争力比较评价[J]. 资源与产业, 2010, 12(3): 66-70.