DIGITAL FINANCE, COMMERCIAL ENVIRONMENT AND
ENTERPRISE’S DUAL INNOVATION

doi:10.13776/j.cnki.resourcesindustries.20240304.002

Abstract

Abstract: This paper, based on provincial panel data and enterprise microscopic dataset from 2011 to 2019, establishes a bi-directional fixed effect model to study the impacts of digital finance on enterprise’s dual innovation and its mechanism from commercial environment. Regression coefficients of digital finance on enterprise’s radical innovation and incremental innovation are positive; the radical innovation can rise by 58.83% and incremental innovation by 49.92% upon digital finance’s rising by 1%, suggesting that digital finance largely boost enterprise’s innovation through coverage and depth, stepping out of “low locked” situation for a higher innovation. Regression coefficients of digital finance on enterprise’s dual innovation in central and western regions are 2.607 7 and 1.237 8 respectively, higher than 0.391 7 in the eastern region, suggesting digital finance exerts a stronger marginal effect on enterprise’s dual innovation in the central and western regions where financial resources are insufficient due to geographic resources occurrence variance, compared with the developed eastern region. On mechanism test, regression coefficients of digital finance to radical innovation and commercial environment are 0.588 3 and 0.429 9, outstanding above 1%, marking their positive relation. Impacting coefficient of commercial environment on radical innovation is 1.032, and mediating effect of commercial environment reaches 74.19%. On incremental innovation, direct effect is opposite to indirect effect, and commercial environment plays a covering effect on incremental innovation. As digital finance gains more supports, improving commercial environment will make enterprises put more resources in radical innovation, thus less in incremental innovation. This paper puts forward suggestions on continuously optimizing digital finance policies, establishing regional digital finance coordination and financial servicing platform to provide enterprises’ dual innovation with external security and to stimulate their inner drive.

Key words: scientific finance, dual innovation, commercial environment, financial reject

摘要： 基于2011—2019年省级面板以及企业微观大数据集，构建双向固定效应模型，考察数字金融对企业双元创新的影响程度，并从营商环境角度出发，剖析数字金融对企业双元创新的影响机制。研究表明：1）数字金融对企业突破式创新和渐进式创新的回归系数均显著为正，数字金融水平每提高1%，企业突破式创新水平提高58.83%，渐进式创新水平提高49.92%，表明数字金融通过拓宽数字金融覆盖广度及加大使用深度推动企业创新水平提高，走出“低端锁定”局面，助力更高水平创新成果产出；2）在异质性分析中，中部、西部地区数字金融对企业双元创新的回归系数分别为2.607 7和1.237 8，高于东部地区的0.391 7 ，表明由于区位资源禀赋差异，与经济基础雄厚的东部地区相比，数字金融在金融资源较为匮乏的中西部地区对企业双元创新推动的边际效应更加突出；3）在机制检验中，数字金融与企业突破式创新及营商环境的回归系数分别为0.588 3和0.429 9，且均在1%的水平上显著，表明数字金融与企业突破式创新和营商环境均有正相关关系；营商环境对企业突破式创新影响系数为1.032，营商环境的中介效应占总效应的74.19%；此外，在企业渐进式创新方面，直接效应和间接效应符号相反，营商环境在影响企业渐进式创新过程中发挥了遮掩效应，随着数字金融支持力度加大，营商环境的改善驱动企业将更多资源聚焦在突破式创新项目中，减少对渐进式创新项目的关注。基于上述研究结论，建议继续优化数字金融支持政策，搭建数字金融区域协调平台和科技金融服务平台，为企业双元创新提供外部保障，激发双元创新的内生动力。

关键词: 科技金融, 双元创新, 营商环境, 金融排斥

CLC Number:

F8325
F2731

TONG Jixin, YIN Ming.

DIGITAL FINANCE, COMMERCIAL ENVIRONMENT AND ENTERPRISE’S DUAL INNOVATION [J]. Resources & Industries, 2024, 26(2): 23-35.

童纪新, 殷铭.

数字金融、营商环境与企业双元创新 [J]. 资源与产业, 2024, 26(2): 23-35.

References

柏培文, 喻理, 2021. 数字经济发展与企业价格加成：理论机制与经验事实[J]. 中国工业经济(11): 59-77.〔BAI P W, YU L, 2021. Digital economy development and firms’ markup: theoretical mechanisms and empirical facts[J]. China Industrial Economics(11): 59-77.〕

陈明利, 2021. 经济政策不确定性、企业金融化与公司创新[J]. 上海金融(1): 66-79.〔CHEN M L, 2021. Economic policy uncertainty, firm financialization and firm innovation[J]. Shanghai Finance(1): 66-79.〕

陈思, 何文龙, 张然, 2017. 风险投资与企业创新: 影响和潜在机制[J]. 管理世界(1): 158-169.〔CHEN S,HE W L, ZHANG R, 2017. Venture capital and firm innovation: impact and potential mechanism[J]. Journal of Management World(1): 158-169.〕

杜金岷, 韦施威, 吴文洋, 2020. 数字普惠金融促进了产业结构优化吗?[J]. 经济社会体制比较(6): 38-49.〔DU J M, WEI S W, WU W Y, 2020. Does digital financial inclusion promote the optimization of industrial structure?[J]. Comparative Economic & Social Systems(6): 38-49.〕

高阳, 田友春, 2017. 金融发展、经济增长与宏观稳定政策: 第二届中国金融经济周期论坛综述[J]. 经济研究(2): 203-207.〔GAO Y, TIAN Y C, 2017. Financial development, economic growth and macro-stability policies:a review of the second China financial and business cycle forum[J]. Economic Research Journal(2): 203-207.〕

辜胜阻, 吴华君, 吴沁沁, 等, 2018. 创新驱动与核心技术突破是高质量发展的基石[J]. 中国软科学(10): 9-18.〔GU S Z, WU H J, WU Q Q, et al., 2018. Innovation-driven and core technology breakthrough: the cornerstone of high-quality development[J]. China Soft Science(10): 9-18.〕

顾宁, 张甜, 2019. 普惠金融发展与农村减贫: 门槛、空间溢出与渠道效应[J]. 农业技术经济(10): 74-91.〔GU N, ZHANG T, 2019. Financial inclusive development and rural poverty reduction: threshold, spatial spillover and channel effects[J]. Journal of Agrotechnical Economics(10): 74-91.〕

顾元媛, 沈坤荣, 2012. 地方政府行为与企业研发投入: 基于中国省际面板数据的实证分析[J]. 中国工业经济(10): 77-88.〔GU Y Y, SHEN K R, 2012. The effect of local governments’ behavior on corporate R&D investment: empirical analysis based on China’s provincial panel data[J]. China Industrial Economics(10): 77-88.〕

郭峰, 王靖一, 王芳, 等, 2020. 测度中国数字普惠金融发展: 指数编制与空间特征[J]. 经济学(季刊), 19(4): 1401-1418.〔GUO F, WANG J Y, WANG F, et al., 2020. Measuring China’s digital financial inclusion: index compilation and spatial characteristics[J]. China Economic Quarterly, 19(4): 1401-1418.〕

郝云平, 雷汉云, 2018. 数字普惠金融推动经济增长了吗?: 基于空间面板的实证[J]. 当代金融研究(3): 90-101.〔HAO Y P, LEI H Y, 2018. Does digital inclusive finance drive economic growth?: empirical analysis based on spatial panels[J]. Journal of Contemporary Financial Research(3): 90-101.〕

侯世英, 宋良荣, 2022. 数字金融对企业研发平滑的影响机制[J]. 中国流通经济, 36(2): 78-89.〔HOU S Y, SONG L R, 2022. Research on the influence mechanism of digital finance on enterprise R&D smoothness[J]. China Business and Market, 36(2): 78-89.〕

华坚, 庞丽, 2020. 科技金融视角下长江经济带经济高质量发展研究[J]. 资源与产业, 22(4): 12-22.〔HUA J, PANG L, 2020. Quality development of Yangtze River economic zone from perspective of scientific finance[J]. Resources & Industries, 22(4): 12-22.〕

黄益平, 2017. 数字普惠金融的机会与风险[J]. 新金融(8): 4-7.〔HUANG Y P, 2017. The opportunities and challenges of digital inclusive finance[J]. New Finance(8): 4-7.〕

江伟, 底璐璐, 胡玉明, 2019. 改进型创新抑或突破型创新: 基于客户集中度的视角[J]. 金融研究(7): 155-173.〔JIANG W, DI L L, HU Y M, 2019. Incremental or radical innovation: a perspective of customer concentration[J]. Journal of Financial Research(7): 155-173.〕

焦瑾璞, 黄亭亭, 汪天都, 等, 2015. 中国普惠金融发展进程及实证研究[J]. 上海金融(4): 12-22.〔JIAO J P, HUANG T T,WANG T D, et al., 2015. The development process and empirical research of inclusive finance in China[J]. Shanghai Finance(4): 12-22.〕

李春涛, 闫续文, 宋敏, 等, 2020. 金融科技与企业创新: 新三板上市公司的证据[J]. 中国工业经济(1): 81-98.〔LI C T, YAN X W, SONG M, et al., 2020. Fintech and corporate innovation: evidence from Chinese NEEQ-listed companies[J]. Chinese Industrial Economics(1): 81-98.〕

李建军, 韩珣, 2017. 金融密度的省际差异及其决定因素: 基于四层次三维度空间分布评价系统的构建与实证检验[J]. 中央财经大学学报(7): 28-44.〔LI J J, HAN X, 2017. The provincial differences of financial density and analysis of its determinants: based on the construction and empirical test of four-level and three-dimension spatial distribution evaluation system[J]. Journal of Central University of Finance & Economics(7): 28-44.〕

刘斌斌, 左勇华, 2022. 金融错配影响技术创新的政府补贴效应分析: 基于企业控股权性质差异视角[J]. 科研管理, 43(1): 61-69.〔LIU B B, ZUO Y H, 2022. An analysis of the government-subsidy effect on the impact of financial misallocation on technological innovation: a study from the perspective of enterprises’ ownership difference[J]. Science Research Management, 43(1): 61-69.〕

刘锦怡, 刘纯阳, 2020. 数字普惠金融的农村减贫效应: 效果与机制[J]. 财经论丛(1): 43-53.〔LIU J Y, LIU C Y, 2020. Rural poverty alleviation effect of digital inclusive finance: effects and mechanisms[J]. Collected Essays on Finance and Economics(1): 43-53.〕

吕劲松, 2015. 关于中小企业融资难、融资贵问题的思考[J]. 金融研究(11): 115-123.〔LÜ J S, 2015. On financing constraints of small and medium enterprises[J]. Journal of Financial Research(11): 115-123.〕

彭春燕, 迟凤玲, 2014. 不同阶段创新企业研发活动及投入特点分析[J]. 科学管理研究, 32(6): 76-79.〔PENG C Y, CHI F L, 2014. R&D activity and its characteristics of innovative enterprises in various stages of development[J]. Scientific Management Research, 32(6): 76-79.〕

齐红倩, 刘倩含, 2021. 中小企业创新产出与融资渠道选择: 数量和质量的视角[J]. 南京社会科学(11): 25-35.〔

QI H Q, LIU Q H, 2021. Innovation output and financing channel selection of SMEs: the perspective of quantity and quality[J]. Nanjing Journal of Social Sciences(11): 25-35.〕

沈梓鑫, 贾根良, 2018. 美国在颠覆式创新中如何跨越“死亡之谷”?[J]. 财经问题研究(5): 90-98.〔SHEN Z X, JIA G L, 2018. How does the US stride over the “valley of death” in disruptive innovation?[J]. Research on Financial and Economic Issues(5): 90-98.〕

宋晓玲, 2017. 数字普惠金融缩小城乡收入差距的实证检验[J]. 财经科学(6): 14-25.〔SONG X L, 2017. Empirical analysis of digital inclusive finance bridging the urban-rural residents’ income gap[J]. Finance & Economics(6): 14-25.〕

谭溪, 2018. 营商环境与金融活动的关系研究[J]. 征信, 36(8): 89-92.〔TAN X, 2018. Research on the relationship between business environment and financial activities[J]. Credit Reference, 36(8): 89-92.〕

唐松, 赖晓冰, 黄锐, 2019. 金融科技创新如何影响全要素生产率, 促进还是抑制?: 理论分析框架与区域实践[J]. 中国软科学(7): 134-144.〔TANG S, LAI X B, HUANG R, 2019. How can fintech innovation affect TFP, facilitating or inhibiting?: theoretical analysis framework and regional practice[J]. China Soft Science(7): 134-144.〕

唐松, 伍旭川, 祝佳, 2020. 数字金融与企业技术创新: 结构特征、机制识别与金融监管下的效应差异[J]. 管理世界, 36(5): 52-66.〔TANG S, WU X C, ZHU J, 2020. Digital finance and enterprise technology innovation: structural feature, mechanism identification and effect difference under financial supervision[J]. Journal of Management World, 36(5): 52-66.〕

滕磊, 马德功, 2020. 数字金融能够促进高质量发展吗?[J]. 统计研究, 37(11): 80-92.〔TENG L, MA D G, 2020. Can digital finance help to promote high-quality development?[J]. Statistical Research, 37(11): 80-92.〕

万佳彧, 周勤, 肖义, 2020. 数字金融、融资约束与企业创新[J]. 经济评论(1): 71-83.〔WAN J Y, ZHOU Q, XIAO Y, 2020. Digital finance, financial constraint and enterprise innovation[J]. Economic Review(1): 71-83.〕

王磊, 景诗龙, 邓芳芳, 2022. 营商环境优化对企业创新效率的影响研究[J]. 系统工程理论与实践, 42(6): 1601-1615.〔WANG L, JING S L, DENG F F, 2022. The impact of business environment optimization on firm’s innovation efficiency[J]. Systems Engineering-Theory & Practice, 42(6): 1601-1615.〕

王韦程, 2015. 中国普惠金融指数框架初探[J]. 金融理论与实践(5): 11-15.〔WANG W C, 2015. A preliminary study on the index framework of inclusive finance in China[J]. Financial Theory & Practice(5): 11-15.〕

温忠麟, 叶宝娟, 2014. 中介效应分析: 方法和模型发展[J]. 心理科学进展, 22(5): 731-745.〔WEN Z L, YE B J, 2014. Analyses of mediating effects: the development of methods and models[J]. Advances in Psychological Science, 22(5): 731-745.〕

吴庆田, 朱映晓, 2021. 数字普惠金融对企业技术创新的影响研究: 阶段性机制识别与异质性分析[J]. 工业技术经济, 40(3): 143-151.〔WU Q T, ZHU Y X, 2021. Impact of digital financial inclusion on enterprise technological innovation: mechanism identification of stages and heterogeneity analysis[J]. Journal of Industrial Technological Economics, 40(3): 143-151.〕

夏后学, 谭清美, 白俊红, 2019. 营商环境、企业寻租与市场创新: 来自中国企业营商环境调查的经验证据[J]. 经济研究, 54(4): 84-98.〔XIA H X, TAN Q M, BAI J H, 2019. Business environment, enterprise rent-seeking and market innovation: evidence from the China enterprise survey[J]. Economic Research Journal, 54(4): 84-98.〕

夏杰长, 刘诚, 2017. 行政审批改革、交易费用与中国经济增长[J]. 管理世界(4): 47-59.〔XIA J C, LIU C, 2017. Administrative approval reform, transaction costs and China’s economic growth[J]. Journal of Management World(4): 47-59.〕

谢平, 邹传伟, 2012. 互联网金融模式研究[J]. 金融研究(12): 11-22.〔XIE P, ZOU C W, 2012. A study on internet based finance model[J]. Journal of Financial Research(12): 11-22.〕

谢雪燕, 朱晓阳, 2021. 数字金融与中小企业技术创新: 来自新三板企业的证据[J]. 国际金融研究(1): 87-96.〔XIE X Y, ZHU X Y, 2021. Digital finance and SME’s technological innovation: evidence from NEEQ companies[J]. Studies of International Finance(1): 87-96.〕

许志端, 阮舟一龙, 2019. 营商环境、技术创新和企业绩效: 基于我国省级层面的经验证据[J]. 厦门大学学报(哲学社会科学版)(5): 123-134.〔XU Z D, RUANZHOU Y L, 2019. Ease of doing business, technological innovation and enterprise performance: an empirical study based on provincial data in China[J]. Journal of Xiamen University (Arts & Social Sciences)(5): 123-134.〕

易信, 刘凤良, 2015. 金融发展、技术创新与产业结构转型: 多部门内生增长理论分析框架[J]. 管理世界(10): 24-39, 90.〔YI X, LIU F L, 2015. Financial development, technological innovation and industrial structure transformation: theoretical analysis framework of multi-sector endogenous growth[J]. Journal of Management World(10): 24-39, 90.〕

尹应凯, 侯蕤, 2017. 数字普惠金融的发展逻辑、国际经验与中国贡献[J]. 学术探索(3): 104-111.〔YIN Y K, HOU R, 2017. The development logic, international experience and Chinese contribution of digital financial inclusion[J]. Academic Exploration(3): 104-111.〕

喻平, 豆俊霞, 2020. 数字普惠金融、企业异质性与中小微企业创新[J]. 当代经济管理(12): 79-87.〔YU P, DOU J X, 2020. Digital inclusive finance, enterprise heterogeneity and innovation of SMEs[J]. Contemporary Economic Management (12): 79-87.〕

张超, 钟昌标, 杨佳妮, 2022. 数字金融对实体企业高质量发展的影响研究: 基于浙江的实证[J]. 华东经济管理, 36(3): 63-71.〔ZHANG C, ZHONG C B, YANG J N, 2022. The influence of digital finance on the high-quality development of real enterprises: an empirical study from Zhejiang province[J]. East China Economic Management, 36(3): 63-71.〕

张峰, 刘曦苑, 武立东, 等, 2019. 产品创新还是服务转型: 经济政策不确定性与制造业创新选择[J]. 中国工业经济(7): 101-118.〔ZHANG F, LIU X Y, WU L D, et al., 2019. Product innovation or service transition: economic policy uncertainty and manufacturing innovation choice[J]. China Industrial Economics(7): 101-118.〕

张贺, 白钦先, 2018. 数字普惠金融减小了城乡收入差距吗?: 基于中国省级数据的面板门槛回归分析[J]. 经济问题探索(10): 122-129.〔ZHANG H, BAI Q X, 2018. Does the digital inclusive finance reduce the income gap between urban and rural areas?: based on panel threshold regression of provincial data in China[J]. Inquiry into Economic Issues(10): 122-129.〕

张蕊, 余进韬, 2021. 数字金融、营商环境与经济增长[J]. 现代经济探讨(7): 1-9.〔ZHANG R, YU J T, 2021. Digital finance, business environment and economic growth[J]. Modern Economic Research(7): 1-9.〕

张勋, 万广华, 张佳佳, 等, 2019. 数字经济、普惠金融与包容性增长[J]. 经济研究, 54(8): 71-86.〔ZHANG X, WAN G H, ZHANG J J, et al., 2019. Digital economy, financial inclusion, and inclusive growth[J]. Economic Research Journal, 54(8): 71-86.〕

张勋, 杨紫, 谭莹, 2023. 数字经济、家庭分工与性别平等[J]. 经济学(季刊), 23(1): 125-141.〔ZHANG X, YANG Z, TAN Y, 2023. Digital economy, household labor division and gender equality[J]. China Economic Quarterly, 23(1): 125-141.〕

赵鹤, 2018. 普惠金融服务下小微企业营商环境探析[J]. 特区经济(9): 130-135.〔ZHAO H, 2018. Analysis on the business environment of small and micro enterprises under the inclusive financial services[J]. Special Zone Economy(9): 130-135.

郑雨稀, 杨蓉, MOHAMMAD H, 2022. 数字金融促进了突破式创新还是渐进式创新?[J]. 云南财经大学学报, 38(2): 49-69.〔ZHENG Y X, YANG R, MOHAMMAD H, 2022. Does digital finance promote breakthrough innovation or incremental innovation?[J]. Journal of Yunnan University of Finance and Economics, 38(2): 49-69.〕

周申蓓, 杨喆, 张桂清, 2023. 营商环境对我国中小企业技术创新的影响: 基于资源基础观的视角[J]. 资源与产业, 25(4): 93-104.〔ZHOU S B, YANG Z, ZHANG G Q, 2023. Impacts of business environment on technical innovation of China’s minor enterprises from perspective of resources-basis view[J]. Resources & Industries, 25(4): 93-104.〕

周泽将, 胡梦菡, 王浩然, 2022. 优化营商环境与抑制民营企业高管职务消费实证研究[J]. 中央财经大学学报(1): 99-109.〔ZHOU Z J, HU M H, WANG H R, 2022. The empirical research on business environment improvement restraining non-pecuniary compensation in private companies[J]. Journal of Central University of Finance & Economics(1): 99-109.〕

朱智洺, 倪金鹏, 符磊, 2023. 绿色复苏视角下“新基建”如何推进高技术产业创新能力提升？[J]. 资源与产业, 25(2): 111-125. 〔ZHU Z M, NI J P, FU L, 2023. How can “new infrastructural construction” boost high-tech industrial innovation capabilities from perspective of green recovery?[J]. Resources & Industries, 25(2): 111-125.〕

CHRISTENSEN C M, 2006. The ongoing process of building a theory of disruption[J]. Journal of Product Innovation Management, 23(1): 39-55.

FORÉS B, CAMISÓN C, 2016. Does incremental and radical innovation performance depend on different types of knowledge accumulation capabilities and organizational size?[J]. Journal of Business Research, 69(2): 831-848.

KANG T, BAEK C, LEE J, 2017. The persistency and volatility of the firm R&D investment: revisited from the perspective of technological capability[J]. Research Policy, 46(9):1570-1579.

LAVIE D, KANG J, ROSENKOP F L, 2011. Balance within and across domains: the performance implications of exploration and exploitation in alliances[J]. Organization Science, 22(6): 1517-1538.

LIN M, PRABHALA N, VISWANATHAN S, 2013. Judging borrowers by the company they keep: friendship networks and information asymmetry in online peer-to-peer lending[J]. Management Science, 59(1): 17-35.

OBSCHONKA M, AUDRETSCH D B, 2019. Artificial intelligence and big data in entrepreneurship: a new era has begun[EB/OL]. [2023-09-25]. https://arxiv. org/ftp/arxiv/papers/1906/1906. 00553. pdf.

DIGITAL FINANCE, COMMERCIAL ENVIRONMENT AND ENTERPRISE’S DUAL INNOVATION

数字金融、营商环境与企业双元创新

PDF

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

References

Related Articles 0

Recommended Articles

Metrics