PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT OF MINERAL RESOURCES POLICIES OF HEILONGJIANG PROVINCE

doi:10.13776/j.cnki.resourcesindustries.20250103.001

Abstract

Abstract: Mineral resources as a vital support to Heilongjiang's economy plays a critical role in local industrial and economic growth. To ensure their sustainability, Heilongjiang authorities have recently issued a series of mineral resource policies, which lacks a systematic assessment on their performances during execution. This paper uses multiple-dimensional data method to discuss the performance of mineral resources policies of Heilongjiang province. This study designed and dispatched questionnaires for different stakeholders, including mineral resource authorities, exploration units and mine entities with 489 pieces of valid returns. Questionnaires had been first validated with their reliabilities and effectiveness through confidence analysis which ensures their internal consistency, and through effectiveness analysis which verifies the accuracy and relativeness. This paper uses fuzzy comprehensive evaluation (FCE) and importance-performance analysis (IPA) to process data for a better understanding of executing performances of different policies. Heilongjiang's mineral resource policies acquire a higher rate in their performance, particularly on policy framework stability, supervision and appropriate mineral resources development. However, some perform poorly, i.e., overlapped issuing mineral rights management on same mineral leads to a low execution efficiency. Regulations regarding “net ore” issue lacks a determined operation standard, increasing complexities and uncertainties in mineral resources management. This paper presents suggestions for Heilongjiang's further mineral resources policies, which provides references in coordinated development among mineral resources management reform, mineral resources development and eco-environmental protection.

Key words: mineral resources, administrative policies, effectiveness;FCE, IPA, Heilongjiang province

摘要： 矿产资源作为黑龙江省经济发展的重要支撑，在地方工业和经济增长中发挥着关键作用。为了确保资源的可持续开发与利用，黑龙江省近年来出台了一系列矿产资源管理政策。然而，政策在实施过程中是否达到了预期效果，仍然缺乏系统性的评估。因此，本研究通过多维度的数据分析和方法论应用，对黑龙江省现有矿产资源管理政策的实施效果进行了深入探讨。为获取第一手数据，本研究设计并发放了针对不同利益相关方的问卷调查，调查对象涵盖了矿产资源主管部门、地质勘查单位以及矿山企业。经过筛选和整理，共获得了489份有效问卷，数据为研究提供了丰富的信息来源。在数据分析阶段，首先通过信度和效度分析对问卷的可靠性和有效性进行检验，以确保研究结论的科学性。信度分析保证了问卷内部一致性，效度分析则验证了问卷测量结果的准确性与相关性。为了更深入地理解不同政策实施效果的具体表现，本研究采用了模糊综合评价法（fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, FCE）和重要性-表现分析法（importance-performance analysis, IPA）对数据进行处理和分析。研究结果表明，黑龙江省矿产资源管理政策总体上得到了较高的评价，特别是在政策框架的稳定性、监管力度和资源合理开发等方面表现良好。然而，部分政策在实际实施过程中仍存在显著不足，例如，同一矿种的矿权出让管理存在层级重叠的问题，导致政策执行效率受到一定限制。此外，关于‘净矿’出让的相关规定在实际操作中缺乏明确的执行标准，增加了资源管理的复杂性和不确定性。基于上述分析，本研究为黑龙江省未来的矿产资源管理政策提出了若干建议。研究成果为黑龙江省进一步深化矿产资源管理改革、推动资源开发与生态环境保护的协调发展提供了重要参考。

关键词: 矿产资源, 管理政策, 有效性, 模糊综合评价法, 重要性-表现分析, 黑龙江省

CLC Number:

F205

LIU Chennan, WANG Chao, LI Wenlong, YANG Shuwang, MA Tianyu. PERFORMANCE ASSESSMENT OF MINERAL RESOURCES POLICIES OF HEILONGJIANG PROVINCE[J]. Resources & Industries, 2025, 27(3): 149-159.

刘陈楠, 王超, 李文龙, 杨树旺, 马天宇. 黑龙江省矿产资源管理政策实施效果分析[J]. 资源与产业, 2025, 27(3): 149-159.

References

白光裕, 梁明, 齐冠钧, 2024.中国清洁能源关键矿产资源进口依赖性风险与应对策略[J].亚太经济(3): 141-152.〔BAI G Y, LIANG M, QI G J.2024.Dependency risk and countermeasures of China's clean energy critical minerals' import[J].Asia-pacific Economic Review(3):141-152.〕

曹宇, 张琪, 李显冬, 2022.“双碳”目标实现的矿产资源法回应[J].中国人口·资源与环境, 32(4): 73-79.〔CAO Y, ZHANG Q, LI X D,2022. Response of the mineral resources law to the achievement of the‘dual carbon’ goals[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 32(4): 73-79.〕

成金华, 帅竞, 赵雨佳, 等, 2023.关键矿产供应风险评估与预测：以铜资源为例[J].资源科学, 45(9): 1778-1788.〔CHENG J H, SHUAI J, ZHAO Y J, et al.,2023.Risk assessment and prediction of critical mineral resources supply for China: a case of copper[J]. Resources Science, 45(9): 1778-1788.〕

顾文博, 罗先熔, 丁继双, 等, 2020.因子分析法在黑龙江大兴安岭塔源地区地电提取测量中的应用[J].桂林理工大学学报, 40(1): 68-75.〔GU W B, LUO X R, DING J S, et al.,2020. Application of factor analysis method in geoelectrochemical extraction in Tayuan area of Da Hinggan Mountains, Heilongjiang[J]. Journal of Guilin University of Technology, 40(1): 68-75.〕

韩世通, 李华姣, 2023.矿产资源供应风险研究进展和前沿[J].资源科学, 45(9): 1723-1745.〔HAN S T, LI H J,2023.Progress of research on supply risk of mineral resources and future directions[J].Resources Science, 45(9):1723-1745.〕

李华姣, 安海忠, 齐亚杰, 等, 2020.基于产业链国际贸易网络的中国优势矿产资源全球贸易格局和竞争力：以钨为例[J].资源科学, 42(8): 1504-1514.〔LI H J, AN H Z, QI Y J, et al.,2020. Trade and competitiveness structure of China's advantageous mineral resources based on the international trade network of industrial chain: a case study of Tungsten[J]. Resources Science, 42(8):1504-1514.〕

李帅乾, 郭忠平, 温卓越, 等, 2024.基于模糊综合评价法的煤矿环境腐蚀倾向性分析[J/OL].煤炭科学技术[2024-12-29].https://link.cnki.net/urlid/11.2402.TD.20240702.1617.002.〔LI S Q, GUO Z P, WEN Z Y, et al.,2024. Analysis of coal mine environment corrosion tendency based on fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method[J/OL]. Coal Science and Technology[2024-12-29].https://link.cnki.net/urlid/11.2402.TD.20240702.1617.002.〕

卢慧娟, 李享, 2020.基于IPA分析法的民宿旅游吸引力研究：以北京城市核心区四合院民宿为例[J].地域研究与开发, 39(1): 112-117.〔LU H J, LI X,2020.Survey on the tourism attraction of Minshuku based on the theory of IPA: taking the Beijing urban core-areas courtyard Minshuku as an example[J]. Areal Research and Development, 39(1):112-117.〕

莫祖英, 侯征, 刘燕权, 2021.基于IPA分析的政府开放数据关键性质量问题研究[J].情报资料工作, 42(1): 88-94.〔MO Z Y, HOU Z, LIU Y Q,2021.Research on key quality issues of government open data based on IPA analysis[J].Information and Documentation Services, 42(1): 88-94.〕

彭忠益, 卢珊, 胡翱, 2023.大数据驱动下国家矿产资源安全现代化治理：逻辑理路与模式构建[J].中南大学学报(社会科学版）, 29(2): 11-21.〔PENG Z Y, LU S, HU A,2023.Big-data-driven national mineral resources security management: logical path and model construction[J]. Journal of Central South University (Social Sciences), 29(2):11-21.〕

任芳语, 陈义华, 陈从喜, 等, 2022.长江经济带矿产资源开发强度时空演化特征及影响因素解析[J].长江流域资源与环境, 31(2): 305-312.〔REN F Y, CHEN Y H, CHEN C X, et al.,2022.Spatio-temporal evolution and the influencing factors of mineral resources development intensity in Yangtze River Economic Belt[J].Resources and Environment in the Yangtze Basin, 31(2): 305-312.〕

邵留国, 蓝婷婷, 2020.伴生性关键矿产资源安全研究综述与展望[J].资源科学, 42(8): 1452-1463.〔SHAO L G, LAN T T,2020.Review of the by-product critical minerals resource security research and prospects[J].Resources Science, 42(8):1452-1463.〕

沈蕾, 罗楚, 高晗, 2016.新常态下旅游目的地品牌体验的IPA分析范式[J].华东经济管理, 30(1): 55-62.〔SHEN L, LUO C, GAO H,2016. An importance-performance analysis framework of destination brand experience under the new normal[J].East China Economic Management, 30(1):55-62.〕

唐珏, 2022.改善矿产资源供需矛盾的税费制度思考与建议[J].财政科学(9): 115-124.〔TANG J,2022.Thoughts and suggestions on tax and fee system to improve the contradiction between supply and demand of mineral resources[J]. Fiscal Science(9):115-124.〕

王佳佳, 王峰, 刘丽, 2023.基于文献计量分析的矿产资源安全研究综述[J].资源科学, 45(4): 683-693.〔WANG J J, WANG F, LIU L,2023.A review of mineral resource security research based on bibliometric analysis[J]. Resources Science, 45(4): 683-693.〕

王江, 2021.论中国战略性关键矿产资源安全的法律监管[J].中国人口·资源与环境, 31(11): 1-10.〔WANG J,2021. Legal supervision of the safety of strategic key mineral resources in China[J]. China Population, Resources and Environment, 31(11):1-10.〕

吴巧生, 薛双娇, 2019.中美贸易变局下关键矿产资源供给安全分析[J].中国地质大学学报(社会科学版）, 19(5): 69-78.〔WU Q S, XUE S J,2019.Supply security analysis of China's critical minerals under the Sino-US trade change[J].Journal of China University of Geosciences (Social Sciences Edition), 19(5): 69-78.〕

吴垠, 孔德, 罗家豪, 2020.矿产资源产权、政府分权与矿业大部制改革[J].中国矿业大学学报(社会科学版）, 22(1): 69-88.〔WU Y, KONG D, LUO J H,2020. Property rights of mineral resources, decentralization of government and reform of super-ministry system of mining industry[J]. Journal of China University of Mining & Technology (Social Sciences), 22(1): 69-88.〕

吴裕根, 司芗, 许书平, 等, 2024.新能源背景下对锂矿资源开发利用的“理性思考”[J].资源与产业, 26(3): 90-96.〔WU Y G, SI X, XU S P, et al.,2024.Rational thoughts on lithium resources development and utilization under new energy background[J].Resources & Industries, 26(3): 90-96.〕

徐亚东, 张应良, 2024.宜居宜业和美乡村建设下农村基本公共服务的优化：基于需求度和满意度的IPA分析[J].农村经济(5): 110-121.

徐占忱, 2023.我国战略性矿产资源供给保障：总体环境、主要短板与体系构建[J].学术交流(6): 105-119.〔XU Z C,2023. China's supply guarantee of strategic mineral resources: overall environment, major shortcomings and system construction[J]. Academic Exchange(6): 105-119.〕

闫冰, 廖欣, 邓双霜, 2024.我国与东盟国家战略性矿产资源产业链供应安全合作研究[J].广西社会科学(2): 44-51.〔YAN B, LIAO X, DENG S S,2024. On cooperation of strategic mineral resources industry chain between China and ASEAN countries[J]. Social Sciences in Guangxi(2): 44-51.〕

杨沛鑫, 2024.资源民族主义主导下的印尼关键矿产战略论析[J].东南亚研究(3): 44-66, 155.〔YANG P X, 2024.An analysis of Indonesia's critical mineral strategy under resource nationalism[J]. Southeast Asian Studies(3): 44-66,155.〕

张宇祺, 李华姣, 安海忠, 等, 2024.产业链视角下关键矿产资源可供性研究进展[J].资源科学, 46(4): 671-686.〔ZHANG Y Q, LI H J, AN H Z, et al.,2024.Progress and frontiers of critical mineral resource availability research based on the perspective of industrial chain[J].Resources Science, 46(4): 671-686.〕

[1]	WEN Hanzhi, TIAN Yi, LI Jiaqi, et al.. MEASUREMENT OF BEIJING'S URBAN COMPREHENSIVE RESILIENCE BASED ON DISSIPATIVE STRUCTURE THEORY [J]. Resources & Industries, 2024, 26(4): 147-.
[2]	HE Letian, YANG Yongqi, LI Rong, et al.. HEILONGJIANG’S INDUSTRIAL CARBON EMISSION SCENARIOS AND PEAKING PREDICTION BASED ON STIRPAT MODEL [J]. Resources & Industries, 2024, 26(1): 162-172.
[3]	JIA Shunshun. ANALYSIS ON INFLUENCING FACTORS OF INDUSTRIAL WASTE WATER DISCHARGE IN EASTERN CHINA：BASED ON STIRPAT FRAMEWORK AND EKC HYPOTHESIS [J]. Resources & Industries, 2022, 24(6): 116-126.
[4]	WANG Yi, HAO Xiuhui, YAO Lixia. TEMPORAL-SPATIAL EVOLUTION OF COUPLING COORDINATED DEVELOPMENT BETWEEN REGIONAL ECONOMY AND ECOLOGICAL ENVIRONMENT BASED ON A CASE STUDY ON HEILONGJIANG PROVINCE [J]. Resources & Industries, 2021, 23(5): 21-30.
[5]	LIN Xiangyi, NIU Yi, LUO Hongyun, et al. ENERGY EFFICIENCY MEASUREMENT AND REGIONAL DIFFERENCE OF INDUSTRIAL ENTERPRISES IN HEILONGJIANG PROVINCE [J]. Resources & Industries, 2021, 23(2): 39-47.
[6]	DI Qianbin, XU Lixiang. TEMPORAL-SPATIAL VARIANCE OF INNOVATIVE DEVELOPMENT OF CHINA'S MARINE ECONOMY [J]. Resources & Industries, 2020, 22(3): 65-73.
[7]	ZHANG Erchao, WANG Song, YU Kexin. COUPLING COORDINATED RELATION OF ORE MINERALS INDUSTRY IN HENAN PROVINCE [J]. Resources & Industries, 2018, 20(5): 90-95.
[8]	GAO Qing, HUANG Zhihua, CHEN Pengyu. COUPLING COORDINATION BETWEEN MINERAL RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT AND ECONOMIC GROWTH IN SICHUAN PROVINCE [J]. Resources & Industries, 2018, 20(4): 69-74.
[9]	SONG Jincheng, ZHANG Zhi, SONG Guoce, et al. TEMPORAL-SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION AND DRIVING FACTORS OF MINING LOCALITIES IN DA-XIAO XING'ANLING AREA [J]. Resources & Industries, 2018, 20(4): 75-81.
[10]	LI Meng,WANG Jianping. . LEGAL ESSENCE, ISSUES AND SUGGESTIONS OF MINING RIGHTS SYSTEM IN CHINA [J]. Resources & Industries, 2018, 20(1): 15-20.
[11]	Cui Muhua. . INDUSTRIALIZATION OF URBAN MINERALS DEVELOPMENT AND USE [J]. Resources & Industries, 2017, 19(6): 64-70.
[12]	Chang Jiang, Zhang Kai, Feng Shanshan.. A CASE STUDY ON SHENJIAZHUANG COAL MINE IN CI COUNTY:VIEWS ON TRANSFORMATION STRATEGY OF COAL INDEPENDENT MINING AREA [J]. Resources & Industries, 2017, 19(5): 23-30.
[13]	SHI Xiao-shi, BAI Zhong-ke, LIU Qing-fe, et al.. GOVERNMENTAL COLLABORATIVE SUPERVISION MECHANISM IN CHINA’S MINERAL RESOURCES DEVELOPMENT [J]. Resources & Industries, 2017, 19(1): 17-22.
[14]	YAN Hai, XU Dan. CHINA’S LAWS IN COAL BED METHANE DEVELOPMENT [J]. Resources & Industries, 2016, 18(5): 29-.
[15]	Zhao Yong.. CREDIT RATING AND FINANCING MECHANISM OF MINERAL RESOURCE ASSETS SECURITIZATION [J]. Resources & Industries, 2016, 18(5): 34-.